4 ms·
I'm a Free Software fanatic. I've often thought of getting a shirt that just says "STALLMAN IS CORRECT" in big block letters, so people know where I'm coming f
by carapace 8y ago
I'm a Free Software fanatic. I've often thought of getting a shirt that just says "STALLMAN IS CORRECT" in big block letters, so people know where I'm coming from. (As an aside, FWIW, the Open Source movement looks, to someone like me, like a largely-successful campaign to undermine the ideology that inspires RMS. But that's beside the point I want to make.)
To me, the current economic systems (left, right, center) are all sub-optimal. I assumed automation would obviate most human labor and usher in a kind of Golden Age (cf. Bucky Fuller, et. al.) Instead, we have pocket computers that serve as strip malls and surveillance devices. (I'm in SF, where we have people living in tents in the shadow of shoddy "luxury" condos. This is hella dystopian y'all.)
To someone like me, if you're programming a computer and NOT working towards a post-historical techno-utopia then you're kinda part of the problem.
We have split the atom: no one should go hungry anymore.
Blah blah blah, RepRaps, blah blah, universal basic income, blah...
- basementcat 8y ago> I'm in SF, where we have people living in tents in the shadow of shoddy "luxury" condos. This is hella dystopian y'all. Why is it dystopian? Some moral and economic systems value individual distinctiveness. What better way to express this distinctiveness than one's choice of living arrangement?
- mindslight 8y agoPresumably the people in tents are not choosing "I want to camp in an urban environment", but rather "I don't want to run on the financial treadmill" [0]. As that makes them useless to the financial treadmill, it is setup so they fall off the back hard and serve as an example to everybody else to keep running. [0] That is to say, to the extent that the houseless can actually be considered making a choice, or at least having made that choice in the past and are now stuck on that path.
- jasonmp85 8y agoWhat.
- ragebol 8y agoNext time you see those people, ask them what they like so much about the tent and what the choice is based on...
- harrumph 8y ago>Some moral and economic systems value individual distinctiveness. What better way to express this distinctiveness than one's choice of living arrangement? Did you just equate suffering from typhus, hepatitis, bacterial infections and other diseases directly tied to homelessness with a "choice of living arrangement"? Did you do this while being aware that homelessness is a "choice" that historically begins with an acute lack of capital that forces an event called eviction?
- basementcat 8y agoIt is absolutely a choice, both on the individual and community level. Some individuals (after consulting their trusted subject domain experts) even choose to give their children the opportunity to suffer from Meningitis and other serious illnesses. Until a society arrives at a consensus in which a sufficiently large quantity of individuals with access to sufficient resources are obligated to offer free housing and other benefits to everyone, that society has implicitly chosen to accept the existence of a population of individuals who live in tents alongside sidewalks.
- carapace 8y ago> It is absolutely a choice, both on the individual and community level. You are correct. I'm one of the few people who actually deliberately chose to be homeless, but I was a rarity. Even so, most of the people who wind up homeless have made one or more decisions that led them to their current state. They made a choice among the options they (thought they) had. A few, like me, were making a lifestyle choice. Most of them just made a bad choice. > Until a society arrives at a consensus in which a sufficiently large quantity of individuals with access to sufficient resources are obligated to offer free housing and other benefits to everyone, that society has implicitly chosen to accept the existence of a population of individuals who live in tents alongside sidewalks. Again, you're correct. In Utah they are building houses and giving them to homeless people. In SF we spent about a quarter of a billion dollars (~$250,000,000) on homelessness last year, and we only have at most about ten thousand homeless people. Most of them would really like some better choices. Not just for housing but also for jobs (a lot of people I met on the street were willing to work if they could.) So, to answer your question from above, that's what makes it dystopian: we as a city are willing and we have the resources, but we're just failing.
- deadmetheny 8y agoChoosing to live in a fucking tent on the street is just 'expressing your uniqueness'? Really?
- kbenson 8y ago> We have split the atom: no one should go hungry anymore. Be careful what you wish for. There's ways to fix that on both the supply side, and on the demand side... and the latter has made for quite a few interesting supervillains in popular fiction. And somewhat counter-intuitively, "fixing" the supply side often just leads to increased demand. Like many problems, it's easy to assume you have a perfect solution before you actually understand the nuances of the problem. Let's not assume "We're smart" immediately means "this is easy". Some problems are inherently hard.
- naniwaduni 8y ago> Be careful what you wish for. There's ways to fix that on both the supply side, and on the demand side... and the latter has made for quite a few interesting supervillains in popular fiction Some would suggest that splitting the atom is more relevant to the latter than to the former :-)
- imglorp 8y agoSee also https://www.reddit.com/r/stallmanwasright https://www.reddit.com/r/stallmanwasright :)