4 ms·
I'd add "difficult to use" to that list. Difficult even for an engineer to use. Terrible. It works great once you figure it out, but it could use a better user
by snvzz 8y ago
I'd add "difficult to use" to that list. Difficult even for an engineer to use. Terrible.
It works great once you figure it out, but it could use a better user and admin experience.
- nightski 8y agoInteresting, used to be in a clan of over 100 people that used it no problem, very few of which were engineers. Not sure what particular functionality held you up?
- TheCapn 8y agoThe only issue I've ever had with it was that friends couldn't seem to connect to my self-hosted server when I shared the URL in Steam chat. Turns out that when you copy/paste from Steam's chat interface (on the old one at least) it automatically prepended "http://" http://" to the URL which Mumble was upset about. These were engineers too, and they didn't realize that pasting an http://URL http://URL to an IP/Port entry might not jive. So take anecdotes with the grain of salt they deserve because his "engineers", my "engineers" and your "engineers" are all vastly different people.
- rhn_mk1 8y agoSetting up the automatic transmission is notoriously causing problems. The lack of echo cancellation and no normalization of audio levels are interfering with discussions as well.
- LinuxBender 8y agoThe 1.3 snapshots have echo canceling and normalization.
- snvzz 8y agoThis was 2-3 years ago. I set up a server and a client. Install some packages, edit some config files. That was the easy part. Once connected to the server, with a friend (another engineer) also connected to the same server, neither of us could quickly figure out how it worked and how to talk to each other. We managed to after a few minutes, but it wasn't immediate, and I presume a normal person would have just given up. My guess is that it imitates some other programs which happen to be similar (I heard about teamspeak?) but that neither my friend nor I have used, and that unlike these programs (presumed) it doesn't have a tutorial or enough cues as to how it works.
- keb_ 8y agoI've heard this before, but between myself and nine of my friends who regular a Mumble server, none of us ever had much difficulty using it. I've always thought it was simple and relatively intuitive. What about it do you find difficult as a user?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- alyandon 8y agoFrom what I vaguely recall experimenting with Mumble years ago - my biggest gripe was the lack of support for anything other certificate based user authentication which complicates the common case of "User X would like to be able to access Mumble from multiple machines".
- keb_ 8y agoYou can export and import certificate files across machines. I've done something like this in the past, and found little issue. I prefer this to something like Discord's centralized account & server system, although I know there should be better alternatives for achieving decentralization.
- alyandon 8y agoRight. The problem was is that the majority of my users were non-technical. So I was left with the choice of: 1) picking voip software that supports username/password authentication that they would be familiar with since virtually every other service on the internet works in a similar fashion vs 2) picking Mumble and trying to explain to them how to import/export their identity certificates for all their owned devices and also explaining that they need to keep the cert handy on a flash drive or store it in the cloud so that they can import it on machines that they might not own
- dcbadacd 8y agoYeah, there should be option in the server to permit multiple clients with the same username.
- literallycancer 8y agoYou click next a few times, speak while looking at a colored bar and move 2 sliders.
- teddyh 8y agoYou’re arguing against someone’s subjective lived experience. Stop that. You could, instead, ask about exactly what part of the “next” clicks and sliders were difficult, but you can’t argue with what someone think they have experienced.