4 ms·
The idea that it is worth blaming a "Jewish merchant class" is itself fairly anti-Semitic. The average person in 13th century England barely had anything to th
by legitster 8y ago
The idea that it is worth blaming a "Jewish merchant class" is itself fairly anti-Semitic.
The average person in 13th century England barely had anything to their name, let alone debt. It would be the lords and tenants who took out massive debts, blamed the Jewish people for daring to lend money or charge interest, and blamed them for society's ills.
- blancheneige 8y agoYou can find writings going back as far as the 800s deploring the disproportionate wealth they had accumulated to the detriment of the clergy and the peasant class [1,2]. This led the Carolingians to outlaw usury all together [3], arguing that money shouldn't create wealth out of itself, and that charging interest put the most pressure on the real wealth creators (farmers). As an example, they were so prominent in commerce that some markets had to be closed on Saturday in Lyon (one of the major hubs at the time) and other major cities for religious reasons. It's not an "idea". It's a fact as reported by historical documents. There is nothing wrong in pointing that out. [1] Saige, Les Juifs du Languedoc, pp. 8, 42 [2] Bédarride. Les Juifs en France, en Espagne et en Italie, pp. 73 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitulary_for_the_Jews https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitulary_for_the_Jews
- empath75 8y agoThis is pernicious bullshit and doesn’t belong here.
- blancheneige 8y agoYour emotional and completely unsubstantiated rebuttals to my well documented response is very unlike HN and doesn't belong here.
- empath75 8y agoI'm sorry did you expect people to have a serious debate on whether Jews deserved to have pictures of horns drawn on them in medieval manuscripts because they loaned money?
- dang 8y agoYou broke the site guidelines in this thread to the point of trolling. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and don't do this again. Note this one: "Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents."
- legitster 8y agoYikes. Just because there is historical evidence of people justifying racism doesn't mean we should! This is a laughably uncritical perspective. If anything, you are proving the link between Marxist theory (accumulation of wealth is inherently evil) and antisemitism.
- blancheneige 8y ago>Just because there is historical evidence of people justifying racism Another instance of retroactively applying terms that didn't apply back then. The misery among the dilapidated populace was very real and the rulers of the time acted accordingly, right or wrong. >doesn't mean we should Nor was I implying so. I am simply providing evidence that the terminology used in the BBC article is inappropriate in that context. >(accumulation of wealth is inherently evil) If you can read French I highly recommend you check out the first two references I cited. They are available on archive.org. It doesn't make the case that accumulated wealth is evil, it emphasizes how the liberal use of debt was severely affecting large swath of the population to the benefit of a small merchant class until it had to be restricted. I was hoping people on HN would be able to grasp complex economical issues without immediately waving the scarecrow of racism.
- legitster 8y agoWe are not doubting the accuracy of your sources. We find your central premise morally repugnant. I could pull up any number of sources from people making charitable cases for slavery or Jim Crow laws, that the original authors were not actually racist but simply protecting society. But taking racists at their word that their motive is pure or free of ignorance is in its own way ignorant. And just because they did not have adequate words to describe their misdeeds does not forgive them for it. To reply to your original post, medieval Europe was very-very antisemitic. This is not a debate about "complex economical issues". The idea that this refugee class had a "stranglehold" is simply not supported. Especially laughable to think that their "strangehold" was worse than the feudal lords of the day! Jewish people were expelled from England. Full stop. If you can't agree that this was an antisemitic act (they didn't kick out merchants, or just the ultra-rich, or break up the feudal lords), I would implore you to rethink how you approach history.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 8y agoWell now, though the existence, dating and authenticity of these documents may be factual; their content is not unnecessarily the unvarnished truth in its every respect.