3 ms·

it helps the public view its government as fallible, corrupt, and absurd This is in agreement with the author's assertion that "WikiLeaks’ motivation is that o

by GHFigs 16y ago

it helps the public view its government as fallible, corrupt, and absurd This is in agreement with the author's assertion that "WikiLeaks’ motivation is that of a court jester, to mock and ridicule the contradictions of a state." What the author is saying in the post is that this is not what his motives were for doing analysis on prior leaks.

grandalf 16y ago
If your interpretation is correct, I don't think the jester analogy holds, since it is the jester who acts/looks absurd.
- Locke1689 16y ago
  No I think you just don't understand what a jester is. In the literate tradition (mostly Shakespearean), the fool is a character of uncommon wit that illuminates the ridiculousness of the system around him. While the joke may sometimes appear to be on the fool, the real joke is on his subject. In this way, Jon Stewart is probably the closest we have to a modern jester. The character that simply looks and acts ridiculous for the amusement of others (your definition) is properly called a buffoon.
  - grandalf 16y ago
    I doubt that was the author's intended definition. His article does not seem to be an attempt to distance himself from the sort of behavior your definition of a jester would commit.
    - GHFigs 16y ago
      Now you're just being obtuse. The author's intent is abundantly clear even if you didn't understand the allusion.
      - grandalf 16y ago
        I'm not intending to be obtuse. Even after a second reading, I still don't think the description you give quite matches Drew's use of the term. In his description, wikileaks is being brash and causing trouble, not just shining a light on absurdity through wit. Further, wikileaks is not using any wit, simply publishing everything verbatim. If Drew hopes to be taken seriously by the US Government and keeping his security clearance (probably highly valuable in his career path) he can't exactly cheer about Wikileaks. This sort of measured, slightly negative review is essentially a bow to power (and there seems like little reason for him to write such an article other than to bow conspicuously before authority). Drew is also a Homeland Security Fellow, whatever that is.

by GHFigs 16y ago

grandalf 16y ago

If your interpretation is correct, I don't think the jester analogy holds, since it is the jester who acts/looks absurd.

Locke1689 16y ago
No I think you just don't understand what a jester is. In the literate tradition (mostly Shakespearean), the fool is a character of uncommon wit that illuminates the ridiculousness of the system around him. While the joke may sometimes appear to be on the fool, the real joke is on his subject. In this way, Jon Stewart is probably the closest we have to a modern jester. The character that simply looks and acts ridiculous for the amusement of others (your definition) is properly called a buffoon.
- grandalf 16y ago
  I doubt that was the author's intended definition. His article does not seem to be an attempt to distance himself from the sort of behavior your definition of a jester would commit.
  - GHFigs 16y ago
    Now you're just being obtuse. The author's intent is abundantly clear even if you didn't understand the allusion.
    - grandalf 16y ago
      I'm not intending to be obtuse. Even after a second reading, I still don't think the description you give quite matches Drew's use of the term. In his description, wikileaks is being brash and causing trouble, not just shining a light on absurdity through wit. Further, wikileaks is not using any wit, simply publishing everything verbatim. If Drew hopes to be taken seriously by the US Government and keeping his security clearance (probably highly valuable in his career path) he can't exactly cheer about Wikileaks. This sort of measured, slightly negative review is essentially a bow to power (and there seems like little reason for him to write such an article other than to bow conspicuously before authority). Drew is also a Homeland Security Fellow, whatever that is.