4 ms·
The article talks about the current private insurance companies moving to a role of supplemental insurance. As an important note on this, that's how it works in
by ineedasername 8y ago
The article talks about the current private insurance companies moving to a role of supplemental insurance. As an important note on this, that's how it works in both Canada and the UK, but in very different ways:
In Canada, private insurance is not allowed to cover anything that is covered by the public insurance. So, no jumping the queue by paying out of pocket or through private insurance. Hopping over to the USA and paying out of pocket is an option for the well off though.
In the UK, there is no such limit, and there is no cap on doctor earnings from private practice, but there are minimums on how much work must be performed for NHS, the public health system. Again, the well off have a way to jump the queue and receive faster/higher quality care.
How these types of factors would play into a US private insurance and private doctor practice of course is unclear, and would be key sticking points in any Medicare for All plan. One thing for sure is that the insurance companies are unlikely to go willingly. Kicking and screaming is more like it, at least if they aren't just nationalized with massive golden parachutes for all of the top brass.
- malandrew 8y ago> but there are minimums on how much work must be performed for NHS So basically doctors are not free in the UK?
- Something1234 8y agoI think the NHS actually pays for their training.
- tfehring 8y agoAs context for this, it's worth mentioning the broader difference between the health care systems in Canada and the UK: - In the UK, the government works like a provider network that provides free* services. Doctors and other medical professionals are effectively government employees. - In Canada, the government works like a health insurer that provides free* insurance. Doctors and other medical professionals work for private organizations that are paid by the government for the services they provide. Discussion of socialized healthcare in the US, including Medicare for All, has exclusively or almost exclusively been based on the Canadian model. *"Free" meaning "approximately free at the margin for the individual, but ultimately funded by taxes."