3 ms·
This is great advice for technical writing, including ads, sitcom script pitches and scientific papers, all of which are addressed to humans with a very limited
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
This is great advice for technical writing, including ads, sitcom script
pitches and scientific papers, all of which are addressed to humans with a
very limited attention span.
In literary writing however, the opposite is true: the person picking up a
novel, or even a short story, wants to read your shit. That's why people read
literature (as opposed to ads or technical manuals). Because they enjoy
reading. And the more of it there is to enjoy, the more the enjoyment lasts.
Like a good meal, good literature makes you want to eat more, More, MORE. And
then have a nice glass of wine and a cigar as you sit in front of your
fireplace on your bearskin rug. Ish.
I mean, have you ever heard anyone say "I'll just pour myself a nice Chianti
and relax with a nice paper on variational autoencoders", or some such? Nah.
People read technical writing because they have to, because they need the
knowledge locked inside. Not because they _like_ it!
This is why technical papers are written so as to minimise the amount of
attention one has to invest in the task of reading them. For instance- a good
technical paper keeps summarising itself. The title is a one-line summary of
the work done. The abstract is a slightly longer summary. The introduction is
a still slightly longer summary, with a short outline of what you are about to
read anyway at the end. The related work section is a short summary of
previous work in the field. The framework section summarises your intuitions
of several years' work, admittedly hiding any excitement you might have felt
about figuring out something new behind a barrage of impenetrable shibboleths
of your field. The implementation section is a short summary of about ten
thousand (wo)man hours of hair pulling. The experiments section is centered on
a visual summary of what was achieved (plots). And the conclusion section
summarises the paper you just read, just in case you missed the point.
It's an awful, ugly, horrible way to write that sucks all the joy out of
writing and reading. It's really a kind of straightjacket. And, to be
perfectly honest, far from the article author's assertion that it somehow
helps "hone your skill", I find that it only achieves what a straightjacket
achieves: restrain you while you go mad.