4 ms·
The wikipedia article you link to does not support the assertion that "everything is an internal representation", but only presents it as one view (representati
by pmoriarty 8y ago
The wikipedia article you link to does not support the assertion that "everything is an internal representation", but only presents it as one view (representationalism). In fact, it explicitly says that "The main alternative to representationalism is anti-representationalism, the view according to which perception is not a process of constructing internal representations."
I also don't see any answer in the quora article to the question of why "these hallucinations seem consistent enough to generate a shared world/consensus reality". In fact, he seems to say the opposite is the case: "all worlds are private worlds".
- ZeroFries 8y agoI linked the wikipedia article to show the main two competing theories. I don't see how direct realism could possible be the case, though, given what we know about perception. > I also don't see any answer in the quora article to the question of why "these hallucinations seem consistent enough to generate a shared world/consensus reality" From David Pearce's answer: "Natural selection ensures that awake world-simulations share similarities. Hence the misconception of a shared experience of external reality. It’s fitness-enhancing, but delusive." An analogy would be each player in a game has their own map of the territory, but overtime, only the players with the maps which reflected the territory accurately enough to continue playing and succeeding in the game would exist.
- pmoriarty 8y agoThat answer seems to contradict his assertion that "all worlds are private worlds", also it seems to presume that there's some way to break through the delusion (else, how would he even know there's any such thing as natural selection in external reality, or even that there is an external reality), but it's not at all clear that there is -- certainly he's made no argument to this effect in the article itself -- and were there such a way, it would also contradict the same assertion.
- ZeroFries 8y ago"all worlds are private worlds" means that all of our experience are necessarily private - I don't have access to your world simulations. The delusion is that we have access to the external world directly. So, breaking through the delusion doesn't mean gaining access to the some shared, public world, it's a recognition that such access is impossible.
- pmoriarty 8y agoIn that case, how does one get access to the external world?
- ZeroFries 8y agoOne can make inferences based on sensory input and a nervous system attuned to the environment over millions of years of evolutionary shaping.
- pmoriarty 8y agoThat already presumes a world view in which there is an external world or environment in which we're in, that we have senses through which we get input from that world. But since all of that is outside our experience (since the model you're arguing for is that we don't have direct access to the external world), the question of how you arrived at that world view remains. The lack of direct access to the external world (if there is one), seems to me to be a hard barrier through which I see no way of breaking, as no matter what you sense, intuit, or think, they are all compatible with any number of ways the external world could be -- such as you're insane, hallucinating, deceived, brain injured, mind controlled, etc, and there's no way to get outside your experience and compare whatver you've concluded, sensed, or believe with what actually is the case. No amount of collaboration or cooperation with others can get you to get at the external world (again, assuming it exists) either, since whatever interactions you have with others is through your own experience, and the same objections regarding their presumed input applies.