3 ms·
Glyphosate is not approved for organic use so that's an irrelevant point. Whether total pesticide load (however you want to measure that) is higher or lower fo
by hammock 8y ago
Glyphosate is not approved for organic use so that's an irrelevant point.
Whether total pesticide load (however you want to measure that) is higher or lower for organic vs conventional, varies widely with crop, location and farming method.
There are toxic organic pesticides like copper-based compounds that persist in the soil. And things like strawberry fields are fumigated with methyl bromide regardless of organic or conventional.
There is not perfect data on the harmfulness of many synthetic pesticides, so it's really hard to make a great judgment on whether it's worse or better for you - unless you have general faith that petroleum derived mystery cocktails are pretty much always going to be harmful.
It's all bad when it comes down to it, we should prefer something like permaculture.
- Tobani 8y ago> Glyphosate is not approved for organic use so that's an irrelevant point. Actually it is a pretty interesting point.
- likpok 8y agoSaying "there's less glyphosate therefore less pesticide" is poor reasoning, because glyphosate is replaced with other, generally more toxic, pesticides in organic crops. It's interesting that organic crops have glyphosate despite it being banned for use with them, but that's a separate discussion.
- thatcat 8y agoNo it isn't. Glyophosate is broadspectrum herbicide for use with gmo glyophosate resistant crops only, there is no organic analogue to this. Also consider that the concentration used is much higher for glyophosate application and the reduced ability for it to be filtered from ground water creates additional externalities.
- likpok 8y agoThere is indeed no organic analog for glyphosate. But there are other pesticides that are routinely applied to organic crops, such as copper sulfate, pyrethrin or rotenone. Both copper sulfate and rotenone are moderately toxic to people, and rotenone is highly toxic to fish.
- thatcat 8y agoRotenone (which has it's usage restricted in omri) and pyrethrin are pesticides, copper sulfate is anti fungal; these non synthetic moderately toxic treatments are replaced with other, generally more toxic treatments in non-organic crops.
- merpnderp 8y agoMethyl Bromide was nearly completely phased out in the US as of 2005. https://www.epa.gov/ods-phaseout/phaseout-class-i-ozone-depleting-substances https://www.epa.gov/ods-phaseout/phaseout-class-i-ozone-depl...
- hammock 8y agoFair point however it wasn't fully phased out until 2016. Here is a study of what farmers have done afterwards: http://calag.ucanr.edu/Archive/?article=ca.2017a0017&sharebar=email http://calag.ucanr.edu/Archive/?article=ca.2017a0017&shareba...