7 ms·
"The US, by contrast, had spent the decades since WWII resisting the assault rifle concept, so that when Vietnam rolled around their fantastically rich and well
by tyingq 8y ago
"The US, by contrast, had spent the decades since WWII resisting the assault rifle concept, so that when Vietnam rolled around their fantastically rich and well-funded military found its infantry outgunned by peasant militias wielding second-hand Soviet rifles."
They would have had M14's in the beginning of the war, with 7.62MM rounds and 20 round magazines. The M16 was lighter, since the M14 had a wooden stock, but the 5.56MM rounds were smaller, and the initial models also had 20 round magazines.
So, I'm struggling with how the M16 would have been even a paper improvement over being "outgunned". I suspect it was more about being lighter and carrying around more rounds of the smaller lighter ammo.
- badlucklottery 8y ago>I suspect it was more about being lighter and carrying around more rounds of the smaller lighter ammo. And viable automatic fire. Yeah, technically you can have a full auto M14 but 5.56mm and 7.62x29mm are really in another league compared to 7.62x51mm when it comes to controllability.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoHaving shot a full auto M1A/M14... yea, there is a good reason the M16 came about instead.
- solidsnack9000 8y agoAt short distances, the relative power of the M14 was no advantage and carried with it the disadvantage of heavy recoil. The natural extension of this is submachine guns which have even less powerful bullets, effective at even shorter ranges.
- azernik 8y agoThe smaller bullet is the point. A 7.62mm bullet is overkill if you're aiming at a person less than half a kilometer away. The essence of the assault rifle concept is to throw away that excess individual bullet power in order to gain volume of fire. The magazine size alone is not a good indicator of practical rate of fire; that has more to do with recoil, which the M16 reduces by using a smaller bullet. For an understanding of the assault rifle concept, I recommend reading the history of the first assault rifle, the Sturmgewehr 44 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StG_44#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StG_44#History): ==================================================== In the late 19th century, small-arms cartridges had become able to fire accurately at long distances. Jacketed bullets propelled by smokeless powder were lethal out to 2,000 metres (2,200 yd). This was beyond the range a shooter could engage a target with open sights, as at that range a man-sized target would be completely blocked by the front sight blade. Only units of riflemen firing by volley could hit grouped targets at those ranges. That fighting style was taken over by the widespread introduction of machine guns, which made use of these powerful cartridges to suppress the enemy at long range. Rifles remained the primary infantry weapon, but in some forces were seen as a secondary or support weapon, backing up the machine guns. This left a large gap in performance; the rifle was not effective at the ranges it could theoretically reach while being much larger and more powerful than needed for close combat. <snip> In the spring of 1918, Hauptmann (Captain) Piderit, part of the Gewehrprüfungskommission (Small Arms Proofing Committee) of the German General Staff in Berlin, submitted a paper arguing for the introduction of an intermediate round in the German Army with a suitable firearm. He pointed out that firefights rarely took place beyond 800 metres (870 yd), about half the 2 km (1.2 mi) sight line range of the 7.92×57mm round from a Mauser Gewehr 98 rifle or less for MG 08 machine gun. A smaller, shorter, and less powerful round would save materials, allow soldiers to carry more ammunition, and increase firepower. Less recoil would allow semi-automatic or even fully automatic select-fire rifles, although in his paper he called it a Maschinenpistole (submachine gun).
- m0zg 8y agoI don't think recoil was the primary driver, actually. Weight was. This becomes readily apparent when you shoot a Kalashnikov side by side with AR15 (a civilian semi-auto variant of select fire M16). A loaded mag for a Kalashnikov is over twice the weight of a loaded M16 mag. And you do need to carry a lot of ammo if you don't want to run out, especially for the AK which is much less accurate. Whoever designed the M16 realized that killing the enemy wasn't really necessary. Heavily wounded enemy is as good as dead.
- azernik 8y agoA Kalashnikov is already an assault rifle - it uses a smaller and lower-recoil bullet than the full-powered rifle cartridges that came before it. An American design that only copied the assault rifle concept would have probably had a similar-weight round to an AK. The M16's even lighter round was the result of a separate American innovation, the Small Caliber High Velocity bullet, which trades bullet size for propellant size. Even smaller bullet than the AK, but a flatter trajectory (hence the improved accuracy, helped along by the M16's interesting operating mechanism), and even lighter weight than first-generation assault rifles.
- int_19h 8y agoThese do not contradict each other. They noted that for the same weight in ammo, it's better to hit the target with a burst three lighter bullets than with a single heavier one. But you also need lower recoil for that burst to be accurate, and M16 is very much designed around that (straight stock etc). The idea that smaller caliber was deliberately less effective on the basis that wounding is just as good as killing is a much later invention, and it only came about back when they switched from M193 to M855, which traded lethality for better armor penetration, and even then as retroactive justification. There's no evidence that this was ever a part of the design spec for any of the M16/M4 series, though, or any official military doctrine. Neither did Soviets consider it when designing AK74. In any case, when 5.56 ammo fragments - as the original mil-spec ammo was designed to, and recently redesigned to do again with M855A1 - it produces wounds far worse than mil-spec 7.62 NATO that preceded it: http://www.rkba.org/research/fackler/figure3.gif http://www.rkba.org/research/fackler/figure3.gif http://www.rkba.org/research/fackler/figure2.gif http://www.rkba.org/research/fackler/figure2.gif
- LoSboccacc 8y ago1/4 of the linked article deal on how the smaller munition is more lethal
- qball 8y ago>So, I'm struggling with how the M16 would have been even a paper improvement over being "outgunned". The round it fires is more suited for the reality of combat, which is that 90% of combat takes place within 100 meters and the last 9% happens within 300 meters of the enemy. In fact, you can't even see a normal target with non-magnified sights at 300m, much less a target that's trying its hardest to hide from you. The M14 is designed to be effective at 600-800 meters. And the cost to being effective at that extended distance is that you have to dump lots of energy into the projectile, which means that the shooter has to deal with a large recoil impulse. If you are taking a shot at 100m with an M14, your sight picture will be completely gone after you fire once. With the M16, however, the recoil impulse is roughly 1/3rd of the M14's (mainly due to the cartridge; the AK-47 uses a similar one energy-wise). Your point of aim doesn't meaningfully change from shot to shot, so if your first shot misses you now have the ability to try again multiple times (and can fire bursts effectively if needed). Maybe there's a slight chance you need to hit your enemy multiple times, but the cartridge makes getting that first shot significantly easier and you can carry more ammunition anyway.
- oeuviz 8y agoBeing forced yearly to shoot at a target 300m away with non-magnifying sights: what makes you think that you cannot see such a target? FWIW: 17 out of 20 rounds have to hit the roughly torso-sized target to pass.
- jabl 8y agoIn real combat targets are not standing still in the open wearing white clothes with concentric black circles? And yes, any infantryman in any army on the planet should be capable of hitting a roughly torso-sizes target with decent probability at 300m.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> In real combat targets are not standing still in the open wearing white clothes with concentric black circles? Neither are normal US military rifle range targets; they are drab green popup targets with límites exposure time on a semi forested range.
- Pamar 8y agoI read a few articles on weapon magazines in 80s about this. 1) while 5.56 is lighter, when it impacts with the human body the bullet will often impart the so-called "tumbling effect" (i.e. instead of keeping its straight course it basically tumbles around inside your flesh - and may create secondary shrapnel if it hits a bone, causing a lot of damage and hydroshock). So yes, if you want to hit someone behind light cover, like a wooden door, 7.62 is more effective, but if you hit directly the resulting damage is equivalent. 2) yes, the bullets are lighter/smaller - this means your average infantryman can carry more magazines as part of his load, so you may be able to fight a bit longer than you opponent packing 7.62. EDIT: added some words to clarify the tumbling effect.
- kyrieeschaton 8y agoTumbling and fragmentation are both highly dependent on terminal velocity and the underlying stability of the round. For instance M855 will not fragment reliably unless it hits ~2700FPS, which out of a 14.5" barrel gives you under 100 meters. In Mogadishu, M855 poked neat little holes, rather than tumbling or fragmenting, in Somali fighters with very little body fat. M193, which is obsolete for military usage but still the most popular bulk round on the civilian market, almost never tumbles in gel tests as it is overstabilized by the 1:7 twist, 16" barrels predominant in civilian ARs.
- potta_coffee 8y ago556 round was originally designed to be fired from a barrel with a different twist, which would allow tumbling more easily.
- aclsid 8y agoThat tumbling effect sales pitch is the most baffling part of this whole story to me. It is great in a lab with ballistic gel on an uncovered target, but hardly the reality out there. I think sooner than later this whole fiasco will be in the past once the move to 6mm cartridges become a thing.
- simonh 8y agoWhen I joined the Territorial Army here in the UK back in the 90s, some smart arse said to the instructor some thing like "but isn't the 5.56 and lighter round and doesn't hit as hard as the 7.62", to which he replied "that may be so son but if someone shoots you up the arse with it, it won't half make your eyes water".
- ataturk 8y agoAlways so much confusion. Ballistics--the smaller 55gr bullet flies at upwards of 3000fps. Yes, you can carry more ammo and make up for the missing mass with more velocity behind it and get a near equivalence of results that way. The .30 cal is only around 2200fps but 165gr bullets carry more force over longer distances. If your maximum range is only 150 yards, you don't care, though. The problem is, there are a lot of variables. Heavy jungle cover can cause 5.56 to deflect, for one example. I'd still take that .30 cal for most situations. .223 was invented for ground hogs! You don't get much accuracy at range with a .22 bullet in 55gr with 1:12 twist, which is why the current versions are 1:7, 1:8 and use 62gr and on up (68, 77, and even 80 and 90 gr favored in competition these days). You can get an AR type rifle to hit accurately at 1000 yards, but it's trickier than going with a bigger bullet out of a larger cartridge. 6.5mm would have been a far better compromise overall. The British had it right and got ignored. Aside from the somewhat puny cartridge, the M16 was a fabulous concept for a wholly different reason--the use of aircraft manufacturing processes and materials which really set it apart. Most of the parts are cast and them machined compared to the forged and welded steel on 1940s and 1950s era tech. The M16 was advanced because of its straight line design, controllability, and lighter weight. An M14 on full auto will beat you to death--it's just the worst. A FAL or G3 on full auto is almost do-able but the M14 downright stinks. The Browning BAR in 30-06 isn't nearly as bad (because it's heavier) and I guess the designers of the M14 thought they could get away with it. The proliferation of the AR type rifles is due to two things: The huge expansion of CNC machining technology which has turned out to be far cheaper than stamping and welding, and the tremendous ease of maintenance and flexibility. My first AR-15 cost upwards of $1000 years ago and now you can buy a "generic" most decent rifle for around $400. This is what scares the hell out of regulators and gun control advocates--technology itself. What underlies the terror for those people is how machine shop tech has been so democratized. Anyone with a modicum of skill can obtain the equipment fairly reasonable and build practically any gun they want. Think: The M16 is from the 1950s and early 1960s. The earliest machine guns date back to the late 1800s, and "decent" gun technology is well over 400 years old at this point. There is nothing, not the chemistry nor any other part of this technology that isn't well established and understood at this point.