2 ms·
I feel like they are allowed to keep their secrets provided they don't make something secret just because it might make them look bad or because it's illegal.
by btilly 16y ago
I feel like they are allowed to keep their secrets provided they don't make something secret just because it might make them look bad or because it's illegal.
But if we let them keep their secrets, how do we learn enough about their motivations to figure out when they are abusing it? Human nature being what it is, if they have the right to make whatever they want secret, they will DEFINITELY use the right to cover up things that make them look bad or are illegal.
Classic case in point, United States v. Reynolds, the case that established the state secrets privilege. When the documents were finally declassified, the only real "secrets" in the report were evidence of serious errors that would have greatly helped the lawsuit against the government.