3 ms·
I feel like whether or not there are Dyson spheres is distinct from whether or not there are sapient civilizations beyond Earth. Unless the argument is that we
by yellowapple 8y ago
I feel like whether or not there are Dyson spheres is distinct from whether or not there are sapient civilizations beyond Earth. Unless the argument is that we don't count as sapient because we don't have Dyson spheres yet?
Hell, we're assuming that Dyson spheres are even possible with such a conjecture. I'm not convinced they are (not without materials that border if not cross outright into magic). It's also not certain if they're necessary to build to sustain any size of spacefaring civilization (artificial nuclear fusion would kinda defeat the point).
- cletus 8y agoDyson spheres at some point were conflated to a structure that is a rigid shell around a star, something for which no known material would be able to support. The original idea of a Dyson sphere is now more often called a Dyson swarm to avoid this confusion. A Dyson swarm (the original Dyson sphere) is a cloud of independently orbiting habitats/bodies/structures.
- yellowapple 8y agoThat seems like it'd be even less efficient. A "swarm" like that would be inherently reliant on maintaining orbits around the target star. In order to capture even a significant fraction of a star's energy you'll need a lot of stations orbiting that star, and they'll need to overlap (i.e shadow out stations further behind them / get shadowed out by stations further in front of them). Even if a civilization's capable of building that many stations to surround a star in a deliberate sort of Kessler syndrome, it ain't clear that a civilization would ever need to do so.