6 ms·
Earlier WikiLeaks releases seemed to expose atrocities and human rights abuses by the US military and government, which represents at least a partial justificat
by philwelch 16y ago
Earlier WikiLeaks releases seemed to expose atrocities and human rights abuses by the US military and government, which represents at least a partial justification. What end does this release serve?
- bryanh 16y agoHype and attention it seems.
- jonknee 16y agoExposure of corruption within our allies. I found things like Afghanistan’s vice president being caught (and released) in the UAE carrying $52 million in cash to be quite interesting. Also the part about Saudi donors are still the driving force in financing terrorism.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- credo 16y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/29/world/29editornote.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/29/world/29editornote.html ( http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1948067 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1948067) has a "note to readers" explaining why the NYT decided to publish the documents
- bl4k 16y agothe US and Britian have turned a blind eye to the opium trade and the associated corruption in Afghanistan in order to appease the local anti-Taliban population. I watched footage last week of British soldiers fighting to free large opium fields from Taliban control so that the real owners can get back to farming. All par for the course. The war on drugs takes a back seat to the war on terrorism
- rottencupcakes 16y agoAs it should. Terrorists are an affront to freedom. Drugs are not.
- grandalf 16y agoTerrorism cannot be stopped (by definition). The affront to freedom is the response to terrorism.
- wan23 16y agoWhat part of the definition says that it can't be stopped?
- grandalf 16y agoDefinition: Terrorism is the creation of fear in a population intended to achieve a political end. What does it take to create fear? Certainly not successful terrorist attacks. Failed ones would work perfectly well too, as evidenced by the underwear bomber, shoe bomber, etc. Things as minor as prank phone calls, etc., will still strike fear into the hearts of the target population. So unless you can tell me that it's possible to stop failed attacks and prank phone calls, you must agree that terrorism cannot ever be stopped.
- ENOTTY 16y agoThat's just semantics. You can stop terrorists by killing them.
- prodigal_erik 16y agoOnly if the rate of killing actual terrorists is greater than the rate of motivating people to become terrorists, usually by killing their innocent loved ones.
- bl4k 16y agoI am not agreeing or disagreeing, just pointing out the blatant hypocrisy.
- commandar 16y agoIt's one of the interesting side notes of the war on terror in general. The Taliban had massively reduced Afghan opium production during their time in power[1]. Opium has always been such an important part of the Afghan economy, however, that production almost immediately picked back up after the US invasion in 2001. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taliban#Opium http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taliban#Opium
- mbateman 16y agoI'm a WikiLeaks skeptic so I can't say I really support this. But I am also a diplomacy skeptic. I'm very suspicious of the effectiveness of our foreign policy and the honesty of our leaders in engaging in it. I'd even go so far as to say that the diplomatic aspect of our foreign policy is equally or more damaging and deserving of criticism than the military aspect. So I'll be interested to see what the more frank, non-public side, as opposed to the endless bullshitty platitudes we get officially.
- LiveTheDream 16y agoCan you explain further what you mean by "diplomacy skeptic"?
- RickHull 16y agoYes -- as they say, war is diplomacy via other means. If you skip over the diplomacy part, then you annihilate anyone who breathes on you wrong. It's hard to imagine how exactly this ethos could reasonably manifest.
- lukeschlather 16y ago> Slovenia was told to take a prisoner if it wanted to meet with President Obama, while the island nation of Kiribati was offered incentives worth millions of dollars to take in Chinese Muslim detainees, cables from diplomats recounted. It's a little hard to tell from the wording, but that might be explicit evidence that the Obama administration is continuing the Bush administration's practice of extraordinary rendition. That or it's just banal, and the Obama administration is trying to find places to take our prisoners we can't release because of bureaucracy and fearmongering.
- philwelch 16y agoNo, it's pretty clear from the context that they're talking about releasing prisoners from Guantanamo Bay. Though it wouldn't be surprising that the Clinton administration's practice of extraordinary rendition (which expanded under the Bush administration) has continued within the Obama administration.
- ajays 16y agoNo, you have it backwards. They're talking about Gitmo detainees who they'd like to release; but can't due to problems in their home countries. For example: there are (were?) a dozen Chinese Uighur muslims who were languishing in Gitmo, having been caught in the dragnet by mistake. They are Chinese citizens, so if they were to be released, they'd go back to China where the authorities would most likely execute them (or lock them away for life). So we'd like to release them to a third country; but everyone's afraid of China's clout and China was applying a lot of pressure to anyone who was even thinking of taking them. So we bribed countries into taking them: some went to Bermuda, some to Kiribati, etc.
- hugh3 16y agoI think the issue with the Chinese is not that the Chinese would lock them away for life (big deal) but that the Chinese were refusing to take them at all.
- sausagefeet 16y ago
- tmsh 16y agoPerhaps it all comes down to whether you have faith in the American diplomatic corps. If you do, this doesn't make sense. If you don't, it does.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's not a matter of faith; one generally wouldn't leak mundane information, only proof of misdeeds. And yet much of this leak is pretty mundane, with barely a scandal to be found in the whole thing.
- tmsh 16y agoPerhaps that's what makes it rather hard to judge. It's almost a higher-order leak (more words and potential relationships, than actions). So sidestepping all the philosophical dualities at work here (Stewart Brand's free/expensive information, the competing 'dishonesties' of releasing diplomacy at work / diplomats keeping secrets), the fact that we don't have a clear idea about what the resulting actions will be -- makes it even harder to judge. A whistleblower exposing something with a clear resultant action (some guy immediately going to jail, e.g.) is much easier to judge. Given the exponential potential routes all this information could go, it seems almost impossible to make sense of whether releasing it is right or wrong.
- hugh3 16y agoYou don't have to have faith in an entire bureaucracy to think it makes no sense. For instance, I don't have "faith" in the IRS. But I don't think anyone should tar up and leak the tax records of every US taxpayer. And I don't have "faith" in facebook. But I don't want a complete leak of every message anyone has ever sent via it.
- mcantelon 16y agoExposure of the underhanded means that the US uses to gather intelligence, for one. Attempting to steal the credit card numbers and biometrics of UN officials violates two UN conventions (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/28/us-embassy-cables-spying-un http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/28/us-embassy-cable...). Attempting to steal the DNA of Western African leaders is even creepier (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/202678 http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/...).
- viraptor 16y agoThese were crimes of governments which are supposed to be trusted and which should work for the people. What end does not releasing every single one of them serve? Why would anyone want to keep them secret?