3 ms·
Yes, thank you, that is exactly my point. The nature of creative work (the kind that is least likely to be automated) is that the output can be highly variable
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Yes, thank you, that is exactly my point. The nature of creative work (the kind that is least likely to be automated) is that the output can be highly variable (think Botticelli's paintings vs 99% of everyone else), and thus it is impossible with that type of work to create a broad base of jobs where lots of people (percentage-wise) are well compensated.
Another way to think of it is not just "repetitive vs non-repetitive" jobs, but "variable vs. well defined output" jobs. It may be currently very difficult to become a radiologist, but at the end of the day a diagnosis is either accurate or it isn't, and those types of "right-or-wrong" jobs are the ones most amenable to automation. So what you're left with are non-automatable jobs where the output can be highly variable, and in those highly-variable output jobs all the gains go to the very best.
- raquo 8y agoCreativity in arts and creativity in engineering and other skilled labour are vastly different. You don't need to be a Botticelli programmer to provide value to your employer because being famous or unique is not how programmers provide value. Programmers are paid for solving business problems. The variability of that is not going to dramatically increase due to automation. Even today you can tell that mediocre programmers are earning good wages while mediocre painters / sculptors / actors are starving. It is not because they have been automated.
- TomMarius 8y ago> Even today you can tell that mediocre programmers are earning good wages Today mediocre programmers still provide value, that's because there are not yet good enough tools that would make these developers obsolete. These tools are coming within the next 10 years.
- Supernaut 8y agoSpeaking as a competent but unexceptional programmer, I find this an alarming claim. Have you any links to worthwhile articles/research on this topic? If I really am going to be thrown on the developer scrapheap, I guess I should start thinking now about how I'm going to keep a roof over my kids' heads.
- raquo 8y agoI'll believe it when I see it. So far none of the website builders, low code platforms, rapid app development tools, etc. made a dent, and not for lack of trying.