4 ms·
I'm extremely wary of trends being stated as if they're inevitable, rather than due to explicit choices. The entire field of popular economics is rife with this
by mindslight 8y ago
I'm extremely wary of trends being stated as if they're inevitable, rather than due to explicit choices. The entire field of popular economics is rife with this, obscuring overt state policies as if they are scientific fact.
> Using Orwellian terms like "Quantitative Easing" or "Troubled Asset Relief", central banks print money and transfer wealth to avoid the market’s verdict.
We're getting closer here. But overall it's not to avoid the market's "verdict" when things come to a head, but something much more persistent and plain.
What's failing about capitalism is the capital part. Obviously not those ever-concentrating pools bidding up every possible investment to avoid being left behind. But rather that capital isn't permitted to remain distributed throughout the economy (which would enable individuals to shoulder their own risks), but instead is trickled upwards through the old playbook of inflation.
This is an explicit choice being made, while its proponents pretend it's unquestionable. We're in an era of unprecedented technological deflation, doing things more efficiently every day, yet the cost of living is still expected to continually rise?!
We're automating away ever more jobs, while simultaneously asserting that employment must remain high. And when it doesn't remain high the alchemists' prescription is to further debase wages and middle class savings, as if the only thing keeping displaced workers unemployed is simply not having the screws turned on them hard enough!
We've had over four decades of steady deflation of computing technology itself. And not simply that a given model would be cheaper tomorrow, but that tomorrow's computer will be able to do things today's literally cannot. Yet we still bought new computers throughout this period, even knowing they would be obsolete on a timescale of several years.
The deflation bogeyman was born out of an era where slow price signals were necessary to negotiate demand. We now have cheap communication, predictive models, and straight up abundance. People will not starve themselves simply because they know food will be less expensive next month.
- leetcrew 8y ago> And when it doesn't remain high the alchemists' prescription is to further debase wages and middle class savings, as if the only thing keeping displaced workers unemployed is simply not having the screws turned on them hard enough! does inflation really hurt the real value of people's retirement accounts? or are you implying that middle class savings are primarily cash?
- mindslight 8y agoRetirement accounts generally aren't liquid, and to the extent they are people really don't want to treat them as such. So yes I do mean to say that the economic power of the middle class is essentially held in cash.
- pdonis 8y ago> does inflation really hurt the real value of people's retirement accounts? Yes, of course it does. The higher the rate of inflation, the higher the rate of return on your retirement account has to be to give you the same amount of buying power when you actually retire.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> does inflation really hurt the real value of people's retirement accounts? It certainly does to the extent the accounts are or hold fixed-dollar-return assets (fixed annuities, bonds, etc.).