4 ms·
While I am not a fan of this style of writing at all (to me it seems overcomplicated when it could make its main points much more simply and clearly), I definit
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
While I am not a fan of this style of writing at all (to me it seems overcomplicated when it could make its main points much more simply and clearly), I definitely agreed with this point:
> In short, what today’s flexible software is threatening is to “free” us from the drudgery of all repetitive tasks rather than those of lowest value, pushing us away from expertise (A) which we know how to impart, toward ingenious Rube Goldberg like opportunities (B) unsupported by any proven educational model.
I've been arguing for some time that people who think that new technology, while killing some current jobs, will also open up a host of new jobs, are really missing the point with what kinds of new jobs are being created. More and more, the types of jobs that add value are the types of jobs where really only the best add much value: think sports stars, actors, Instagram influencers, but also graphic designers, writers, and even programmers to an extent. In those jobs, the very best take the vast lion's share of income because what the best produce is valued so much more highly than everyone else. Meanwhile, all kinds of "repetitive" jobs, even current high value jobs like radiologists or pathologists, are at risk of being automated away.
The problem is you can't really run an economic system where only a very few percent of people take all the gains, at least not one that is socially stable or resembles liberal free market capitalism of the past 100 years.
- raquo 8y agoI don't think people do repetitive, automatable jobs because they can't do any other kind of job, but rather because our current market conditions make it a good choice for them. And by market conditions I mean everything from wages to availability and cost of education to immigration policies and welfare benefits. Once the dust has settled after major advances in automation I don't see why people wouldn't be able to work as managers, designers, programmers and engineers even if those were the only jobs left in the economy (but of course there are many more skilled jobs that will not be automated anytime soon). It's just a matter of training and expectations. I don't think a world where people only need to work 20 hours a week, and where we have 5x the number of every kind of skilled specialists we have right now is a bad place to be. And it doesn't require ditching capitalism entirely, just regulating it differently (taxation, welfare, etc.). It's only the transition to such a world that is worrying because it will happen faster than people can adjust, not the end result.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>The problem is you can't really run an economic system where only a very few percent of people take all the gains... I could be wrong here, but I think the commenter, and the author of the article, are speaking on the bipolar nature of creative jobs like manager, designer, or programmer. The value of different designers and programmers to, say, Apple and Google, is kind of bipolar right now. The concern being that it will be more bipolar in the future. Right now we have the 5 or 6 figure a year sort of "warm body" programmer, and you are correct in asserting that anyone can do that job. But, we also have the 7 figure programmer, and only the very best can do that job. I think their concern is what if the 7 figure Apple designer turns into a high 7 or 8 figure Apple designer, and the "warm body" designers get less and less over time? Kind of like athletes. A few 8 or 9 figure soccer and basketball players, and then all of the others. Most of whom will never be able to make a living at their sport professionally. (Consider: How many young girls did our athletics infrastructure chew through to get Simone Biles? I don't really know? But I'm guessing it was a lot.) I think it's a fair concern. Certainly well within the purview of the sort of concerns we should be war gaming out at the policy making level. All that said, yeah, your world of 20 hours a week sounds pretty sweet to me.
- im3w1l 8y agoWith a best of the best system, you've got to work all waking hours to have a chance of being the best. So rather than 20h each, we should see some people working a lot, and then a lot of people realizing they have no chance of making it and dropping out of the system completely.
- bilbo0s 8y agoYeah. We're at a crossroads. There's different roads we can go down. There's different ways this whole thing can develop. What we look like when we come through this might be pretty ugly? Or not? We don't really know right now? We just have to hope that society's stewards are being responsible and considering these very real mechanisms when settling on plans for our long term future. These forces are not going anywhere. Technology is with us to stay, the only question is how we live with it.
- plainOldText 8y ago> More and more, the types of jobs that add value are the types of jobs where really only the best add much value [...] In those jobs, the very best take the vast lion's share of income because what the best produce is valued so much more highly than everyone else. Your perspective is in agreement with studies in network science, which have uncovered that in a wide variety of physical, biological, and man-made phenomena, the network models follow a power law distribution, and as a result, you end up with situations such as, for example Kim Kardashian having 130M followers, while the average Instagram user probably has about 1-2k followers. Other similar distributions: income, research paper citations, world wide web, etc. It appears that uneven distributions are inevitable in free human networks, or as Will & Ariel Durant once noted: > Nature smiles at the union of freedom and equality in our utopias. For freedom and equality are sworn and everlasting enemies, and when one prevails the other dies.
- specialist 8y agoYup. "in agreement with studies in network science" Attention economy -> preferential attachment -> winner takes all. It's just math. -- "power law distribution" Every market will lead to a dominant first place, runner up second, distant third, and everyone else. (Roughly) For a long while now, markets have been consolidating (local -> regional -> national -> global). So now instead of multiple markets with their own champions, we have a handful of markets with respectively fewer champions. It's just math. -- "freedom and equality are sworn and everlasting enemies" Nice quote. Thanks. Nicely compliments Kevin Phillip's formulation of wealth vs democracy. Without deliberate, aggressive redistribution, accelerating inequity is inevitable. It's just math.
- plainOldText 8y agoPerhaps I’m wrong in my observation, but my overall sentiment of your comment is that you’re too eager to simplify things. Unrelated to the above part of my comment, but: > Without deliberate, aggressive redistribution, accelerating inequity is inevitable. People are willing to embrace redistribution way too hastily, while ignoring higher order consequences. If we embrace more aggressive redistribution, to what extent, how effective, to what long term cost, etc? Perhaps redistribution is so seductive because it promises some laudable social outcome while also being easier to understand than competing alternatives. Top-down engineering solutions to complex human problems should cast doubts imho. That is not to say we shouldn't strive to solve the challenges of our society, but we ought to always be mindful of its complexity. Tangentially related to our conversation, but I found this paper on politics + complexity [1] – albeit still a draft – helpful. [1] https://www.academia.edu/38433249/Multiscale_Localism_Political_Clarity_under_Complexity https://www.academia.edu/38433249/Multiscale_Localism_Politi...
- Consultant32452 8y ago>The problem is you can't really run an economic system where only a very few percent of people take all the gains, at least not one that is socially stable or resembles liberal free market capitalism of the past 100 years. I don't understand this sentiment in the context of the world I live in. If you had to choose which point in history and which place you'd be born into, not knowing your race/gender/sexual preference/family income/level of health it seems very obvious to me that the best time in all of history to be born is right now. And the list of places that are even considerable as best places to be born to is fairly small, but slowly growing. If right now is the best possible time to be born for the "common man" and most people reading this are in list of best places, how can we be so concerned about social stability? Do you disagree with that general sentiment? Over all, is there a different time in history you'd choose to live? Now I want to be clear that I'm not claiming today is perfect/ideal/etc. in any way. We surely have many problems in life. But I genuinely don't understand where this feeling comes from. Could you help me understand?
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI'm just speaking for my experience in the US, but I definitely disagree that now is the best time to be born. For your "average person" the best time to be born was about 50-80 years ago (obviously racial disparities complicate this a great deal). But my viewpoint also seems to bear out in lots of social science evidence in the US, where there has been an explosion of "diseases of dispair", e.g. suicide, drug-use, disability, etc. among large sub-populations in the US.
- Consultant32452 8y agoNot just racial disparities. Women make up slightly more than half the population. Even if we just limit our scope to white men, I don't see much argument for the idea that white men have it nominally worse off today than they had it 50-80 years ago. I only see that they are not as far ahead of women and racial minorities as they were 50-80 years ago. And 70 years ago was the end of WWII. I assume it was an accident to include that in your range. Regarding the explosion of "disease of dispair", suicide, drug use, etc. I do acknowledge that but I don't see how it's related to the OP. The OP appeared to be talking about relative wealth as being socially disruptive. Let's run a thought experiment there. If we could magically decimate the wealth of everyone with over $1 Billion, without changing anything else, do you believe the "diseases of despair" situation would improve? I personally do not believe it would. My personal belief on that issue is that we've gained one kind of social safety net but lost another. There's seemingly countless ways in which the government offers programs to help people avoid certain kinds of suffering: unemployment insurance, medical care for the poor, disability insurance, social security, etc. But somehow we've managed to lose the other kind of social safety net... strong social ties to the community. I believe this latter thing is the root cause of the disease of despair, and I don't believe any check cut by the government, or any tax program that reduces the wealthy can resolve that problem. Just one anecdotal piece of evidence here is the TED talk about our lack of understanding of addiction. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PY9DcIMGxMs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PY9DcIMGxMs
- teekert 8y ago"The problem is you can't really run an economic system where only a very few percent of people take all the gains, at least not one that is socially stable or resembles liberal free market capitalism of the past 100 years. " I agree partly, you can run it but it has to be social. To put it very blunt and anti-social, the rich will have want to buy off being robbed by the poor, or build very high fences around their lives, in almost all aspects. In other words, if this continues: revolution and unpredictability. I used to love (and still do, but we're growing apart) Ayn Rand but I think this is something she never predicted. Rational, smart people, willing to work but somehow ending up at the wrong side of the fence. The rich becoming the looters, disrespecting rights of the "poor".
- specialist 8y agoI'd rather we argued about outcomes. I'm okay with a Gini coefficient between 0.30 - 0.35. In other words, somewhere between Germany & Australia. The USA is currently 0.45 and climbing. Not good. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gini_since_WWII.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gini_since_WWII.svg I really don't care how we accomplish it. Radical cashectomies, UBI & Medicare for All, Warren's taxation of equity (eg %3/yr for > $1b), Green New Deal. Whatever works.
- GarvielLoken 8y agoYou can, it has already been done. History repeats itself etc etc. The Roman state was powered by slaves ( which is the ancient form of automation ) and the plebs were basically unemployed citizens. It worked, it created a system where the richest people competed for power by public moves and schemes.