4 ms·
> How bad is the handling with that system inoperative? The need for this came from adding bigger engines to a small airframe, which required putting them too f
by tzs 8y ago
> How bad is the handling with that system inoperative? The need for this came from adding bigger engines to a small airframe, which required putting them too far forward so they'd clear the ground.
My limited, layman understanding from the assorted coverage and posts by people who seem to understand this thing is that almost all the time the bigger, more forward engines do not cause a problem and MCAS doesn't have to do anything. It is just that on those very rare occasions when you get into a situation where it does make difference, MCAS helps you recover safely.
So, if the system can detect a problem with the AoA data and lock out MCAS, and tell the pilots that MCAS is disabled (and the pilots understand that this means some protection is gone), they should be able to finish the flight safely with at most a need to avoid pushing any limits that might get it into a situation where they do need MCAS.
Only those very very rare situations where the plane both gets into a situation where it needs MCAS and it simultaneously has an AoA sensor problem would be a problem.
I think this is why they can get away without triple redundancy and majority voting on the AoA sensors for MCAS. Losing MCAS is not an "Oh my god we are going to die!" situation. It's a "fly more conservatively for the rest of the flight" situation.
- mveety 8y agoI don’t know specifically about the MAX, but based on the thrust vector if a pilot in a stall put in more power before nosing down the plane would pitch up and you’d be put into an even deeper stall. The MCAS is there to nose down automatically for you if a stall is detected.
- phire 8y agoMy understanding is that in the 737-8MAX, pushing the control column fully forwards isn't necessarily enough to recover from stall (or potentially even a near-stall AOA). MCAS was designed to trim the stabiliser down in a high AOA situation, to give the pilots a bit of extra downwards control authority and help them recover from a stall. To compensate for flying with MCAS inoperative, pilots will need to manually trim down when recovering from a stall. I assume they will just train the pilots to always trim forwards when recovering.