11 ms·
If I Sleep for an Hour, 30 People Will Die (2016)
- Tomte 8y agoFirst glance at the headline: maybe about sleepy driving. Another glance at the word "Opinion" above it: probably just clickbait. Onward to the first paragraphs: Oh shit. A very touching story, about a real hero in dark times. (Why is this under "opinion"?)
- strstr 8y ago(It’s a book review.)
- msviss 8y agoThe ability to forge and evade is why I am against the substitution of paper instruments with electronic alternatives. Be it self driving cars, passports, cash or what have you. I feel that people who are not scared about “it happening here” are: ignorant of their country’s history, delusional about human depravity and a bit “racist” in the sense that “only Germans” or “only Russians” can do these crimes. One “good” thing about Trump winning is every leftist who, until then, assured me really terrible things couldn’t happen in the US, all of the sudden realized what an happen. (I’m not American, I come from a country that within living memory murdered tens of thousands of its own children )
- jsbaby608 8y agoWhat 'terrible' things have happened with Trump? Im in the us and it's business as usual.
- pgeorgi 8y agoICE detaining families, splitting kids from their parents (apparently with no idea who belongs to whom), with work done by minimum wage paid security folks - some of whom appear to see unfettered access to these kids as a bonus and molest them?
- DrScump 8y agoICE detaining families, splitting kids from their parents Both were widespread under Obama.
- GunlogAlm 8y agoThis doesn't appear to have been the case: https://www.factcheck.org/2018/06/did-the-obama-administration-separate-families/ https://www.factcheck.org/2018/06/did-the-obama-administrati... https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/immigration-border-crisis/fact-check-did-obama-administration-separate-families-n884856 https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/immigration-border-crisis/...
- brightball 8y agoDHS does not get along with these agencies apparently and have put out full statements on the matter. https://m.facebook.com/homelandsecurity/posts/2231821660163791 https://m.facebook.com/homelandsecurity/posts/22318216601637...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- leereeves 8y agoAccording to the FactCheck article you linked, the law requires that families either be separated or released. > In 2016, a court ruling limited how long children with their parents could be in family detention centers. Obama released families. Trump has taken a stricter stance against immigration, which requires some unpleasant enforcement, but once again according to FactCheck, he did order that families be kept together as long as possible: > On June 20, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing Nielsen to keep families in custody together “during the pendency of any criminal improper entry or immigration proceedings involving their members” at least “to the extent permitted by law and subject to the availability of appropriations.”
- cbg0 8y ago
- faitswulff 8y agoNot sure if trolling, but look up family separation, Vietnamese deportation, the sales of national park lands, incitement to violence against journalists, the rise in hate crimes, etc
- leereeves 8y agoWhy do you include > the sales of national park lands How is that comparable to what the Germans or Russians did? For that matter, how is any of that comparable to gulags or Auschwitz?
- pgeorgi 8y agoThe forger also helped people refuse participating in the Vietnam war or get out of war-time Algeria. Concentration camps or Gulags aren't the only reason for people needing to leave the country without its government learning about it.
- leereeves 8y agoAre you suggesting forgers should forge documents to help people illegally enter the United States, to get around Trump's restrictions?
- pgeorgi 8y agoI don't care about the United States. Other than that, "needing to leave the country" (what I said) is very different from "illegally enter" (what you said), starting with the direction of travel.
- leereeves 8y agoI agree, which is why I was confused. If any of Trump's policies have led someone to feel they need to leave the US, they don't need forged documents to do it.
- 7952 8y ago
- 0003 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_administration_family_separation_policy#Administration_issues_%22zero-tolerance%22_policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_administration_family_se...
- sk5t 8y agoThe terrible thing is that the nation has elected an incompetent babyman as its global representative and commander in chief of the world's most powerful military. The good thing is that the outcome suggests that the country is somewhat fault-tolerant in the face of ridiculous leadership.
- jacquesm 8y agoI'd add a 'so far' as a caveat. This isn't over yet, unfortunately and typically the venom is in the tail.
- roenxi 8y agoIt doesn't actually matter what has or has not happened under Trump. There is a sizable contingent of people on the left who believe the President of the USA is a criminal supported mainly by racists. I personally disagree but those beliefs open up too very easy prongs of attack to counter 'it can't happen here' arguments: * They likely believe the situation went from everything being fine to everything being not fine at extreme speed in 2016 * They have just been subjected to 2 years of evidence of their political tribe's relative impotence removing a criminal from high office Those beliefs should be a lot easier to push the idea that government capability is the threat, not the governments current intentions.
- paganel 8y agoFor similar reasons I’m against the centralization of Government data into one big database (so to speak) where they’ll be able to find almost anything about you in just a couple of clicks.
- Moodles 8y agoWithout getting political (expecting downvotes), what comparable "terrible things" have happened under Trump that are at all similar to Soviet Russia or Nazi Germany?
- skookumchuck 8y agoThe point isn't really what Trump has done, it's that leftists are suddenly discovering that it won't always be "their guy" with all that power, and that misusing that power against them is a real possibility. Be very, very careful what excuses one makes when "your guy" is overreaching and expanding power.
- MereInterest 8y agoIn terms of things that have happened so far, the responses to your sibling post cover it pretty well. However, that was not was being referred to. GP's post refers to the feeling that such things could not happen in the United States. There has, for a long time, been a sense that atrocities were not able to occur in the United States, due to some combination of individualism, enumerated rights, American exceptionalism, etc. Rising white nationalism and racism was a driving force in Trump's election. Since then, he has been a symbol for a darker sides of politics that people previously imagined to be absent in the US. It is not that terrible things on a similar magnitude to Soviet Russia or Nazi Germany have happened. It is that the US is not immune to those things happening. (This is not meant to imply that family separation, rolling back of trans rights, and tacit approval of white supremacist violence are not terrible. They are deplorable actions, and I do not want to lessen their impact.)
- Moodles 8y agoThey feel such things can't happen in the United States... and the example they give to contradict that is Trump? I merely ask how it is comparable to Nazi Germany. I still find it amusing merely asking my question rewards me with downvotes. I don't care about my own HN karma, but it's a shame to see comments in general getting downvoted for this. It's a ridiculous comparison.
- solipsism 8y agoI wonder how easy it would be to create a browser plugin that would hide any hacker news thread that mentions Trump. What's going on in the responses to this thread is ridiculous.
- chess93 8y agoPerhaps a neural network that detects politically charged posts? Sounds like a fun side project.
- deadbeef404 8y agoNot that hard :). Add this as a tampermonkey script for a simple version. Array.from(document.getElementsByClassName('comment')).forEach(x => {if (/Trump/.test(x.innerText)) { x.innerText = 'Trumped' }})
- lainga 8y agoWhere'd all my bloody Bridge tutorials go?!
- u801e 8y agoIf this was a newsgroup, then what you propose could be accomplished through a killfile. Basically, one could add a rule that would hide a post if either the subject or body contained a certain phrase, and, optionally, could hide any replies to that post.
- jr1488 8y agoIf by "Russians" you are referring to the Holodomor and the like -- as Solzhenitsyn rightly points out, it was perpetrated against Russians, not by them. The commissars and leadership were 90% Jewish Bolsheviks. The supposed German atrocities of WW2 were in direct response to those same Bolsheviks. The history surrounding both events have been highly twisted and rewritten by the victors.
- mabbo 8y agoBut that same forgery can be used for nefarious proposes as well. Human trafficking is a huge industry and the easier we make it the worse it will be. I'd rather see us stand up to totalitarianism so that forged papers aren't need.
- pjc50 8y agoThe guy in the original article forging passports almost exactly matches the criteria for human trafficing, except he didn't ask for payment. (consensually getting someone across a border is widely criminalised)
- lixtra 8y agoHuman trafficking is about criminally moving people AGAINST their will in order to exploit them.
- pjc50 8y ago> assured me really terrible things couldn’t happen in the US Guess they're leftists who didn't know their history. Or weren't aware somehow of what Black Lives Matter is all about.
- pgeorgi 8y agoThe article is about a person who forged papers starting in WW2 and up to the 70s to get people out of dire situations. It ends in "“I did all I could when I could. Now, I can’t do anything,” he said. Surely, though, the rest of us can." Not so easy anymore, with all the biometrics and cryptographically secure data on a microchip embedded in today's passports.
- gumby 8y agoI think the point isn't "now it's time for someone to forge papers" but "there are plenty of ways to help and other people with more energy can take them up" From raising awareness, convincing governments, running for office, donating money and/or labor...just volunteering on a crisis line is a huge help.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoIn the context of the original article, and the current world, it appears that far fewer are willing to bring personal risk than in the past. My guess - and it is a guess - is rather than signing an online petition, forwarding a meme, or attending a demo, in the past direct action, civil disobedience, underground networks and activism was more often used. I suspect that in today's world many of those would be viewed as terrorism or at the very least imprisonable.
- cromulent 8y agoReally interesting discussion. I would add a guess that living a long life has become so normalized and expected that risk taking behaviour has become more eschewed.
- hopler 8y agoAcitvists have always been attacked as "terrorists". Look at the brutal repression of the Civil Rights movement, where imprison was one of msnycworries when faced with a murderous police force and general public.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago
- caprese 8y agoI wonder how his documents would compare to listings on Oasis and Alphabay these days.
- fiftyacorn 8y agoReminds me of "Portrait of a Young Forger" by Marian M. Pretzel
- ceoddevelopment 8y agoThe word is workful
- gerbilly 8y ago> By his 19th birthday, he had helped save the lives of thousands of people by making false documents to get them into hiding or out of the country. What an immense privilege it must have been to be in a position to help so many people.
- js2 8y agoDiscussion from 2016: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12621548 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12621548
- noego 8y agoIt's interesting to consider the parallels between the power/responsibilities carried by Kaminsky, and our own lives. It is estimated that we can save a human life for $2000. Which means that each of us faces a similar dilemma even if we don't realize it: "If I go on an international vacation, 1 person will die" This is not to say that we should live a spartan life and donate every dollar to charity. I wouldn't expect Kaminsky to forego sleep entirely either. But it's a tradeoff that is worth being conscious of, the next time we spend money on things we don't truly want or need. https://www.givewell.org/giving101/Your-dollar-goes-further-overseas https://www.givewell.org/giving101/Your-dollar-goes-further-...
- scarejunba 8y agoIt is undoubtedly clear to me that a human life is less valuable to me than my having a MacBook Pro because I am both fully aware of how much it costs to save people and consciously choose not to do so. So life isn't really precious. It is only precious in terms of its relationship to me. My family is precious and my friends are precious. Life? Life is cheap. Things I value more than life for life's own sake: * The aforementioned MacBook Pro * A trip to Switzerland * Two months of my personal trainer's sessions * My bicycle * One month of rent in SF * Having my car for a couple of months * A celebratory lunch for my team The real disconnect isn't that we're imperfectly choosing our spending. It's that we tell the lie that life is precious. It is not. I will buy my parents a computer and a tablet soon. I will do this for them knowing it brings them some small pleasure. I will do this knowing that doing so will doom a child.
- montenegrohugo 8y agoIt sound horrible, morbid and even psychopathic, but it is the truth. Most people do not think about life in such practical ways (read: realistic), instead it is idealized and made an abstract concept. It is not. You consciously choose, every day, egoistic actions that harm other people. You could have saved countless lifes, yet you did not. Do not pretend to care when you do not. Same thing goes with eating meat. Animals aren't things. They feel, they suffer. And we make them suffer. Just because they taste good. But harming a dog? Abandoning a dog to get a new puppy? That is horrible! But is it, really? Or is it just the same thing we do every day?
- mikeash 8y agoThe comments about the dangers of moving toward un-forgeable documents remind me of the xkcd about spacebar heating. https://xkcd.com/1172/ https://xkcd.com/1172/ Official documents being susceptible to forgery is a bug. Like many bugs, it can be exploited for noble purposes, but it’s still a bug. The right way forward isn’t to keep this bug around so our systems can remain vulnerability-compatible with their 1940s versions, it’s to find a way to support the use cases you want to keep. I don’t know how to do that exactly, but on the other hand, I bet none of you know how to convince governments to stick with forgeable paper documents either.
- gerdesj 8y agoThough he was a skilled forger — creating passports from scratch and improvising a device to make them look older — there was little joy in it. “The smallest error and you send someone to prison or death,” he told me. “It’s a great responsibility. It’s heavy. It’s not at all a pleasure.” Years later he’s still haunted by the work, explaining: “I think mostly of the people that I couldn’t save.” Hero.
- mariuolo 8y agoAnd if he sleeps too little, he'll create lousy forgeries that will also cause people to die.