8 ms·
Wikileaks says it is under attack
- tomjen3 16y agoIt won't matter - the guy at the Guardian has already posted to twitter that they will publish the papers even if wikileaks go down.
- garply 16y agoWhoever is behind the attack should just DDOS all of the media sites that have the leaked information. In seriousness though, the attack probably will moderate the damage slightly, as I imagine Wikileaks was going to publish all the raw documents on its site, whereas the other sites will probably just give summaries of the important points. Sure, Wikileaks will eventually come back up and have all the raw data available, but the peak viewing time was going to be today. If I were trying to minimize number of eyeballs viewing the raw documents, I'd take this approach.
- tmgrhm 16y agoI think the newspapers will link to full copies for perusal, but include highlights/excerpts in their articles. The biggest problem the DDoS creates, in my eyes, is that anyone reading about the leaks will go to Wikileaks.org and find a dead page and then forget about it, thus minimising their exposure to the other doings of Wikileaks.
- wladimir 16y agoI'm pretty sure the raw data will be available as torrent :) No need for any website...
- hugh3 16y agoAssange is such an attention whore that I wouldn't put it past him to turn off all his servers and send out a press release saying "Look at me, I'm under attack!"
- iwr 16y agoLet's wait and see. Besides, whore or not, the world is a better place due to wikileaks.
- hugh3 16y agoThat remains rather unproven, but I don't feel like arguing about it.
- citricsquid 16y agoHow so? What changes have actually happened because of the leaks that happened? We'd all forgotten within a week.
- steveklabnik 16y agoIt has to start somewhere. It hasn't gotten better yet, but it still might. History is hard to see while it's being made...
- hugh3 16y ago... or it might get worse! Potential informants, no longer trusting the US to be able to keep their identities secret, clam up. Intelligence dries up. Bombs go off. People die. Dogs and cats living together. Mass hysteria.
- ThomPete 16y agoWhat evidence do you have that that is actually what will happen?
- nano81 16y agoThe point is that leaks of this magnitude have much broader effects than you can imagine. You can argue about whether it is a net positive or negative, but there WILL be negative consequences and to pretend otherwise is just fooling yourself.
- trotsky 16y agoAny of the state actors unhappy with this release have undoubtedly looked at the issue somewhat closely. They'd know: * a DDOS wouldn't change anything * wikileaks has decent contingency plans, and are prepared for a lot beyond a simple denial of service * It'd just get wikileaks in the news more in the run up to the release Conclusion: Misguided amateur patriots or complete fabrication
- madair 16y agoit wasn't that long ago the fbi had hoover, i think you give bureaucrats too much credit
- deutronium 16y agoOn the Wikileaks Twitter feed: "Now is a good time to download some "history insurance" https://thepiratebay.org/torrent/5723136/WikiLeaks_insurance https://thepiratebay.org/torrent/5723136/WikiLeaks_insurance 1:04 AM Nov 26th via web" Yes, you're right, even if the servers are down, they can leak the key via twitter etc. to this file.
- ancymon 16y agoAnyone knows what's the point of stalling those "leakage"? It's becoming quite annoying for me: all those newses about what it is going to be about or newses about DOS attack. Why can't they just publish it already? Or maybe they should setup wikileaksleaks.org for leaks about wiki leaks...
- steveklabnik 16y agoThey don't publish them immediately because they want a worldwide simultaneous release with the New York Times, Der Speigel, and the Guardian.
- Zakuzaa 16y agoAlso called 'Embargo'.
- zeeone 16y agoOff topic, but I had to ask this: Am I the only one here that thinks that this upcoming leak will pose a threat to the national security and should be stopped?
- aw3c2 16y agoThe national security of what country? I suspect it could improve the security and life of some affected countries. If there was no exploitation and shady operations that seriously harm others, there would not be such excitement in the US government.
- zeeone 16y agoThe national security of all countries involved. Sensitive diplomatic information is often better handled by diplomats. Unleashed to the masses, it may cause unnecessary aggression, maybe even riots somewhere. Not to mention that it puts a lot of people's lives at risk.
- blueben 16y agoBest handled by diplomats? Because us unwashed masses can't handle the truth, public debate just second-guesses those who are in charge, and we should really leave the important things to the ruling class?
- 16y ago
- madair 16y agonational security has a direct-line relationship to the bottom line of u.s. startups... we get to witness the dividing of those who will make an atom bomb, and those who will not. (i.e. if your business depends on imperialism, you are an imperialist. now consider oil and hegemony)
- dabeeeenster 16y agoLooks like the Guardian have gone live with this already... http://grab.by/grabs/1f0906251076b904622300ccf4496b71.png http://grab.by/grabs/1f0906251076b904622300ccf4496b71.png
- Andrew_Quentin 16y agoSo strange. You grow up all your life being told how great democracy is, how we live under the rule and process of the law, how we are a tolerant and free society which values free thinking, which values the right to speech, however offending or off that speech may be. As you grow up however, you kind of start realising that much of the above is sort of true in theory, but not true in practice, especially if the freedom of speech concerns a criticism of those who have more power than you. It is because power corrupts that many people had to die to ensure that we today live in relative freedom. It is because those in power have the means to subvert criticism and silence such criticism that it has been necessary for many to be shunned, called lunatics, heretics, traitors, or to die, so that truth can be spoken to power, so that truth can be spoken to power in order to preserve our liberty. The right to free speech does not apply only to the dissemination of pictures of cats. A society and its adherence to its principles are tested and shown when power is seriously criticised, when power is or has the potential to be seriously undermined, not, when someone writes about lolcats because people even in North Korea can write about lolcats. I am very amazed that people even consider an attack on wikileaks to be 'good', or that a real attack on the wikileaks founder would have been even better, because, they consider the leak to be a potential attack on their own percieved or real self interests, such as the image of their nation around the world, or that the world may find out that real life is so much more interesting that any fantasy book that can be written or any idealistic principle that can be formulated. I consider it amazing that anyone may even think of supporting an attack by what may be a state actor, not because of any breach of law, but because it is embarrassing to such state actor. We are not children any more, and if our principles are to die with the passing of our childhood, then we might need to consider the principles in the first place, their truth, their applicability, whether our generation of grown up adults wants to stand by them and continue supporting them. If we as the people wish to turn a blind eye to government censorship, to dirty tactics by governments through reputation damage by means of charges unsupported by evidence, if we are going to eat up the effective propaganda (PR I read somewhere began as an industry after the second world war and was based on the effectiveness of Hitler's tactics) and blindly state that such an attack is a good thing whether by anyone, let alone the government, simply because our perceived interest may potentially be damaged or undermined, not because of any reason of principle, not because we consider it to be an illegal activity not even based on reasonable moral arguments, but simply and only because it is a criticism which embarrasses, then something has gone badly wrong since the time I was born and now that I have grown up. Truth is Power. Suppression of truth allows power to corrupt. That is why we have such principles of freedom of speech and such principles are not quantifiable simply by our embarrassment when criticised, or even more woringly, by the embarrassment of politicians.
- danenania 16y ago"The US state department has said the release will put many lives at risk." Yes, because the US government clearly has great concern for unnecessary loss of life :-/
- yters 16y agoIt does. Especially under McChrystal there were numerous deaths of American soldiers due to the very restrictive ROEs.
- nhangen 16y agoI think Assange underestimates the power that this information wields, and as a result is being reckless and potentially dangerous to those he's trying to "protect" under the guise of freedom. This is a dangerous game to play, especially for someone with little experience doing so. I don't know how I feel about the concept of Wikileaks itself, but I do feel uncomfortable that this man seems to enjoy playing God. Replace one tyrant with another and you end up in the same place.
- AndrewMoffat 16y ago> I do feel uncomfortable that this man seems to enjoy playing God. You can't help but wonder if he is playing out some international hacker of intrigue fantasy, but I think that even if he is, that mindset does more good for his cause than it does harm.
- nhangen 16y agoI'd like to hear why you think the latter portion of your statement is true. The first part I can agree with, but I'm not sure how it helps...I think he's in over his head.
- AndrewMoffat 16y agoSelf-image can be a powerful feedback loop that reinforces other qualities. I think that the types of things he would value if his self image was of a "persecuted international man of intrigue" would be things like vigilance, perseverance, cunning, suspicion, and those would be helpful to his role @ Wikileaks due to the nature of his work. My $0.02.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI can't say I have a lot of pity for Wikileaks. I feel -- and you guys are welcome to trash me on this and I'm sure you will -- that taxpayers have paid billions of dollars to our government to perform diplomacy. And diplomacy always involves the keeping of secrets. It did 500 years ago, and it will 500 years from now. So no matter how much arm-waving you want to do about freedom and truth, nations still have to have secrets. And while I oppose the secrecy state that we've created, it's the taxpayers that have created it, not wikileaks. It's our monster to tame. Assange neither represents us nor has our best interests in mind. Assange is no representative of freedom or honor in my book. In my book he's a low-life self-promoting pimp of anarchy, and I imagine what goes around will certainly come around to him. If you want to leak a few documents about the Iraq war as part of informing the public that it's not going well, then fine, more power to you. Hell I'll contribute to your defense fund. The truth has to be free. But if you're going to dump all the state department cables from countries all over the planet on the internet, then you have attacked my country. And while I'm all with you and fully support getting to an open society, that doesn't even begin to forgive an act of war like this. This discussion has gotten to absolutes -- people are arguing that everything needs to be open. Other people are arguing that everything must be secret. The truth is that neither position is going to work, and I have to say I'm pretty pissed at Assange at taking such a serious issue like openness and crapping all over it. He's done more harm to his own cause with this than his opponents could ever help to accomplish. For the next ten years we'll have story after story trickle out about what harm this has caused. It will make a nice backdrop to even further draconian security measures. There is a space between anarchy and the security state. Let's find that spot and live there.
- vaksel 16y agoI feel like they are allowed to keep their secrets provided they don't make something secret just because it might make them look bad or because it's illegal. Remember, everything they do...they do in our name.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoLook I have no problem with taking drastic action against the government for keeping too many secrets. But this is a bridge too far. This is like using a nuclear bomb to put out a city that is on fire. It's not going to have the effect that its supporters want. Quite the opposite.
- btilly 16y agoI don't like Assange. However my belief is that the kind of stuff he is leaking is similar to the kind of stuff that governments manage to figure out about each other through spying anyways. Therefore the risk of injury is not as big as the government would have you believe, but the risk of public embarrassment is huge. And incidentally, if you really believe in the first amendment, his actions should be entirely legal. At this point he is part of the press, and the government has no right to limit his free speech, or the freedom of the press. OK, so I don't like him. But there is a well-known principal of constitutional law that the important precedents are set by people who are hard to like. Because if they were nice people, they wouldn't have been in court in the first place. But by defending the rights of least likable people, we defend everyone's rights. If you want to compare it to something, compare to the publication of plans for making a hydrogen bomb. The government tried to sue to stop publication, and failed. Now you can find discussion of the subject on wikipedia at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teller-Ulam_design http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teller-Ulam_design. Which matters more? The Constitution, or the release of information that could kill tens of millions of people? The actual ruling of the court was that the Constitution mattered more!
- nhangen 16y agoIt's not as black and white as a first amendment issue. This isn't press, this is sensitive and classified information. He could play a much greater role in change were he to use this information in a more strategic fashion than to recklessly publish 100% of it.
- btilly 16y agoThis isn't press, this is sensitive and classified information. In what way, at this point, is Assange not part of the press? Remember, a large part of the Constitution is meant to provide checks and balances to prevent government from being able to abuse its power. The proper Constitutional role of the press SHOULD be to inform the public on the actions of the government so that the public can get properly outraged about things they do not agree with.
- 16y ago
- jacquesm 16y agoBefore disparaging wikileaks and/or the person of Julian Assange for whatever shortcomings they've got it would be good to contrast this with the opposite, say a leak from inside the North Korean or Iranian regime. Such a leak would be applauded and the perpetrator would be declared a hero by those exact same governments that would like wikileaks to go away. Don't shoot the messenger. And realize that whatever your government does it does so in your name too. If it can't stand the light of day because it is illegal or embarrassing then maybe it should not be done.
- waterlesscloud 16y agoWhat if the reason it's kept out of the light of day is that it makes the already difficult job of people working in my nation's interest even more difficult? Much of what's here is not in the least surprising, but having official confirmation just makes it that much more complicated for people out there trying to make things better. Not all secrets are eeeevil, you know.
- jacquesm 16y agomy nation is a different one from yours. And that goes for a large number of people. Not all secrets are evil, however I'm fairly sure that the fact that some secrets in fact are evil is what drives the feeding frenzy around wikileaks. If all that came to the surface would be an impeccably functioning diplomatic machinery with the highest standards for ethics I highly doubt this would get as much press and attention as it does.
- sigzero 16y agoOr we can just not like Mr. Assange for needlessly putting peoples lives in danger? I don't know why but when I read the headline I chuckled. It is so apropos.
- paradoja 16y agoWhose life has been threatened by him? Please provide sources.