7 ms·
How did two groups of fish separately evolve genes for making antifreeze?
- VirtualAirwaves 8y agoI know how to make antifreeze! Hide her nightie.
- misterhtmlcss 8y agoI love this stuff. Coolest science to learn and read about. Thank you for sharing it!
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoAgreed. I also want to thank good scientific journalism writing when I see it. Translating scientific news into a format geared toward a layperson is very difficult, and I thought this author did a great job. I thought his "thralala" neologism was great and made for a better read that was also easier to understand.
- skywhopper 8y agoInteresting article about some of the mechanics of DNA and evolution. But I wanted to call out a confusing use of the increasingly ambiguous word “partner” here: “There, she and her partner, Arthur DeVries, studied the notothens”. What sort of partner? Research partner, clearly. Oh, but with some googling you can find that they are married, so also romantic/life partner. I appreciate the sentiment behind the takeoff in the use of this phrasing, but it inevitably leads to confusion in communication. Can we come up with a better word that is not so ambiguous? And if not, can we (or at least the editors at places like The Atlantic) try to clarify what sort of partner when the meaning is ambiguous?
- dmckeon 8y agoWhy? This is science reporting, not tabloid journalism. We don’t need to know the marital status, gender preference, dietary restrictions, previous relationships, etc. Good writing about science is plenty. And “spouse” is a fine word if needed.
- flukus 8y ago> We don’t need to know the marital status, gender preference, dietary restrictions, previous relationships, etc. I agree, but a lot of science reporting and especially TV/movie documentaries are going down the path of "telling a story" and focusing more on the process and characters involved rather than facts. This is particularly true from outlets like the Atlantic, so if GP went in with the expectation of that kind of article I can understand how they got confused.
- Simon_says 8y agoI agree with you, but then why bring it up at all?
- Qwertystop 8y agoThey didn't bring it up. > What sort of partner? Research partner, clearly. The fact that the two happen also to be married need not be related to the use of the word.
- hycaria 8y agoI directly understood it as both romantic and work partner.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- taneq 8y agoFrom the headline I'd immediately guess many groups of fish were living in above-zero waters adjacent to sub-zero waters containing food. Eventually some of them experienced a random mutation which made them slightly less freezy and earned them free food! The account of the actual sequence of mutations required was really interesting, though. It's good to see an article go into that kind of detail!
- bitL 8y agoMaybe the mutation wasn't really random? I wouldn't be surprised if at some point we find that the "90% unused brain capacity" is actually doing some long-term adaptation computations and then uses various signals to put that information into reproductive cells...
- Drakim 8y agoThe "90% unused brain capacity" is a myth. Furthermore, the brain doesn't control evolution though "thinking", it's powered by natural selection outside the body.
- caprese 8y agocited by 555 other papers suggesting RNA changes from life experience -https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4333222/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4333222/ so people are working on reproducing this and understanding this process more, to say more clearly: scientists are actively researching how evolution can happen without natural selection
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> how evolution can happen without natural selection This sounds incoherent. What does "natural selection" mean to you?
- cahooon 8y ago
- Vinnl 8y agoNot really relevant, but too much of a fun fact for me not to share: the partner's name is "DeVries", which I'm guessing has a Dutch origin, and literally translates to "TheFreeze". (I suspect its etymological origin is more related to Frysia, though.)
- cbcoutinho 8y agoNot quite, 'de Vries' in Dutch translates to 'the Friesian'.
- shifto 8y agoNo, that would be DeFries.
- Vinnl 8y agoExactly, although the word probably derives from that - hence my remark about its etymological origin.
- vectorEQ 8y agovries means freeze. even though not used like that specifically, you are right in your thought that vries means freeze. "ik vries" -> "i freeze". friesland's name is disputed though between being founded by a guy named 'friso' and that 'Fries' means 'peoples with curly hair' :D - so much for logic & linguistics :D!
- Vinnl 8y ago> so much for logic & linguistics :D! Which is why I didn't want to go into the actual etymology, because the only reason it was a fun fact is because the current meaning of the word is freeze, regardless of what it referred to in the past :)
- Kirth 8y ago"Vriesland" is an old spelling for Friesland (Frisia).