4 ms·
Is there any data on whether hyphenation actually improves reading speed? My hunch is that the problem it mostly solves is packing a greater number of words on
by munificent 8y ago
Is there any data on whether hyphenation actually improves reading speed? My hunch is that the problem it mostly solves is packing a greater number of words on a fewer number of printed pages, thus saving the printer money.
But my impression as a reader is that I stumble over hyphenated words much more often than I am distracted by a particularly ragged right edge or a big river in a justified paragraph.
- ivanhoe 8y agoI have no data on it, but I presume it depends on a language heavily. In languages like English where words are not that long it'd be very counter-intuitive that hyphenation could help with reading speed as we don't read individual letters, we read word by word. Splitting words in two parts can only slow down the reader. In languages like German with a lot of very long words built by combining a few simpler ones, I presume hyphenation can be important tool to avoid having big holes in the text that could make it hard for readers' eyes to follow the lines of text.
- chronogram 8y ago> very long words, hyphenation important Oh don’t worry I prefer words like “Kindercarnavalsoptochtvoorbereidingswerkzaamhedencomitéleden” to be one thing so I can just gloss over the blob. Only have to read the blob once to recognise the shape and know what it refers to. With hyphenation it’s a different blob every time, so then I might spend time reading 60 letters. Hyphenation is for newspapers, where space is money.
- int_19h 8y agoOn a small screen - say, smartphone - it might not be an option.
- Tomte 8y agoIf you want to skip over the blob, sure. But if you want to read it, hyphenation makes it much easier. Because your claim that there would be a "different blob every time" is not false, but misleading. There are different blobs, but they are all ones that can berecognized by shape. Because such long words would certainly be split up between their constituent words, not between random places. This actually makes a hyphenated composite word easier to read than the very long non-hyphenated form.
- chronogram 8y agoYes I see where you’re coming from if you want to read the blobs, but I cannot recall a situation where I wanted to read them more than once. Not in Dutch or German, so I do really appreciate the lack of hyphenation when reading those languages (on my phone screen especially). Maybe you do get into those situations?
- Tomte 8y agoArwe you really saying that words above a certain length don't interest you when reading an article with that word? And what is the "more than once" thing supposed to mean? Hyphenation helps the first time, too.
- misnome 8y agoI think they are referring to the way many (most?) people read most words - recognising the shape rather than reading the individual letters. Presumably if your language contains several common and unique long words you quickly start to recognise the shape and so no longer need to read the letters.
- Tomte 8y agoYes, I understood that. But the hyphenated parts are also words (if you're hyphenating intelligently), so you recognize their shapes just as well, probably even better.
- bhaak 8y ago> Because such long words would certainly be split up between their constituent words, not between random places. At least for German, this is not a requirement. Hyphenation doesn't happen at random places but at syllable boundaries. The only care that you should place up hyphenation is that it shouldn't lead to possible misreadings. "Ur-in-stinkt" being the classic example. Only split that word at the first, never at the second possible hyphen.
- burfog 8y agoI certainly have my own data point. When my kids are reading, they stumble very badly over every hyphen. I think it is long past time to agree that hyphens were always a very bad idea, along with mucking up the font designer's intended kerning. There is nothing wrong with ragged right text. For best readability, we should prefer to break lines such that we avoid breaking up significant logical parts of text. If reasonably avoidable, don't break: clause, phrase, sentence, quotation, etc.
- beardyw 8y agoIn that article I came across "of-ten". It took me a noticeable amount of time to work out what it meant.
- Biganon 8y agoWeird, that means the "no hyphens in words shorter than 6 letters" rule the author suggests isn't respected in the very article that discusses the rule
- yorwba 8y ago"Currently only IE/Edge supports this property (with a prefix), however Safari does support hyphenation character limits using some legacy properties specified in an earlier draft of the CSS3 Text Module."
- omnimus 8y agoIt's true that it doesn't so much sense in digital. Two reasons exist - mobile devices and aesthetics. Many people regard text set to justified as something luxurious or "high". The problem is that justified text is hard - it needs human intervention and proper settings and composer engine. Basically you can properly do it only in LaTeX with some plugins and indesign. The way it is handled in browsers must be computationally efficient so browsers do it in half assed way. Dont use hyphenation in digital except where stuff would overflow.