4 ms·
That's an interesting point. For example, whenever people talk about increasing road building to alleviate traffic these days on places like Reddit, they are im
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
That's an interesting point. For example, whenever people talk about increasing road building to alleviate traffic these days on places like Reddit, they are immediately lectured to about how more roads just cause induced demand and they don't actually cause traffic to go down.
For highly desirable cities I have to wonder if the same thing is true for housing. I mean, it feels like even if you doubled the amount of housing in SF that you would just cause more people to want to congregate in SF while 3rd tier cities and rural areas would empty out even faster.
- wbl 8y agoAnd that makes all the new people better off. But we can measure this effect and I recall the city economist found every 3٪ increase in housing stock dropped rents 1%.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> For example, whenever people talk about increasing road building to alleviate traffic these days on places like Reddit, they are immediately lectured to about how more roads just cause induced demand and they don't actually cause traffic to go down. People misunderstand how that works. If you have a road which is excessively congested, the congestion suppresses demand. Nobody wants to sit in traffic for two hours, so people stay home or make use of flexible hours to commute at what would otherwise be less convenient times etc. If you add capacity to the road then the congestion gets better, but not by as much as you would have expected if you looked at the existing traffic, because the fact that it got better caused some of the congestion-suppressed demand to return, which made it less better. So the net result is that it got a little better when you expected it to get a lot better. But that doesn't mean you can't fix it by adding supply, it just means you need enough supply to satisfy the whole demand, including the demand that was suppressed by the high congestion (or in the housing case by the high prices). Of course, in the road case there are also alternative ways to satisfy demand, like building more housing so that people can live closer to where they work and don't have to drive as many miles.
- troydavis 8y agohttps://shelterforce.org/2019/02/19/why-voters-havent-been-buying-the-case-for-building/ https://shelterforce.org/2019/02/19/why-voters-havent-been-b... has a detailed examination of what happens after supply in one sub-market (say, mid-priced townhouses) increases. While I don’t agree with all of it, he brings up a key metric: “cross-price elasticity of demand” between sub-markets.
- raldi 8y agoSee page 28 of http://openbook.sfgov.org/webreports/details3.aspx?id=2199 http://openbook.sfgov.org/webreports/details3.aspx?id=2199 — when a new apartment building opens in SF, 84% of occupants move in from elsewhere within the city.