3 ms·
Might not significant improvements in mass transit might help this problem quite a bit as well? If a commute from 20-30 miles away was trivial, more people on t
by ineedasername 8y ago
Might not significant improvements in mass transit might help this problem quite a bit as well? If a commute from 20-30 miles away was trivial, more people on the lower end of the economic scale could live further from urban centers where housing prices are at their peak.
- losteric 8y agoYes, but if you're far enough that the housing pricing works out the density will also be too low - translating to many stops or areas feeling underserved.
- ineedasername 8y agoVery good point, that is in fact what happens after about 40 miles out from NYC. In fact a bus company recently tried a new direct route from a town at the 39 mile mark and cancelled it after 5 weeks when the average ridership was 10 people (on a 53 seat bus). Some mornings there were none. Just a little closer, around 30 miles, is still viable though. And three spidering train routes service a large population between 5 and 30 miles out, and around which townships have flourished over the last few decades. I think it's common for people further out from the train line to drive to it and park and ride. That does add to the commute time though. Much as I have mixed feelings about Elon Musk these days, his Boring company gamble does seem to have potential to leapfrog current bottlenecks on mass transit.
- sanxiyn 8y agoYes, mass transit is one answer because it warps geography of time. It is also why it is so political: route of mass transit has massive impact on nearby housing market.
- aetherson 8y agoBut in California, major transit extensions take a decade or more to complete and cost tens of billions of dollars. It would be hard to build enough housing to make a serious effect on prices: it's probably five times harder to build enough transit to have a serious effect on prices.
- tomjakubowski 8y ago> in California, major transit extensions take a decade or more to complete and cost tens of billions of dollars Recent data from LA Metro: * In 2012, Expo Line phase one (Downtown to Culver City) opened, six years after construction broke. * In 2016, Expo Line phase two (Culver City to Santa Monica) opened five years after construction broke. * In total, the 15.1 mile Expo Line cost $2.5 billion. * Also in 2016, the Gold Line Foothill Extension, Phase 2A (Pasadena to Azusa) opened after five years of construction at a cost of $735 million. * Gold Line Foothill Extension, Phase 2B (Azusa to Montclair) is expected to cost ~$1.5 billion, involves some major additional work (relocating existing commuter rail and freight rail tracks), and is expected to open in 2028, about nine years after it broke ground.
- aetherson 8y agoFair enough, maybe I should've said "Bay Area" instead of California.