3 ms·
Oh they get it, they’re just looking out for themselves. Property owners account for 72% of the voting block and have strong roots in the community where renter
by arcticbull 8y ago
Oh they get it, they’re just looking out for themselves. Property owners account for 72% of the voting block and have strong roots in the community where renters tend to be more transient [1]. In America, as a property owner, your home is probably your largest investment. The perception here for better or worse is that more housing means less demand for yours, so you lose money.
It’s like wondering why the foxes don’t vote for razor wire around the chicken coops. Not in a malicious way, it’s just not in their interests.
For what it’s worth I own, and am fine with new development because I think it’s not nearly as detrimental as it’s made out to be. I think the community benefits both directly with diversity of people and indirectly as it supports more jobs but I feel very much in the minority.
tl:dr; it’s because renters don’t vote and voters don’t rent.
[1] https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/renters-and-voting/ https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/renters-and-voting...
- gumby 8y agoCame to say this so thanks for being so clear. In Palo Alto I've seen an additional nuance. When I first moved here (1984) houses were underwater and there was lots of student rental. As Stanford built student housing, most of the houses became single family but there was an aggressive effort to keep the environment diversified (e.g. two SRO hotels downtown, section 8 requirements, and a lower median income than surrounding towns). Then in the late 90s/early 00s the real estate interests took over the city council. It was in their interest to restrict supply for the reasons you stated; if you built it was to build larger, higher priced units as replacement for existing stock which are marketed to newcomers. It's great to have new neighbors, but when you move in and worry about the cost of your mortgage, you aren't really interested any more about the structure and balance of the community. Taller buildings have been resisted as have most new multifamily residences. As a result, the median income has shot up, teachers, cops, firefighters and the like can no longer live here. It's a different and much less interesting place.
- masonic 8y agoa lower median income than surrounding towns The "surrounding towns" are East Palo Alto, Menlo Park, and Mountain View. When has any of these had a higher median income than Palo Alto?
- gumby 8y agoThrough the late 1990s except EPA (since it became a town in the 80s). Nowadays there are still some homeless folks, but there used to be plenty of people living in homes on public assistance along with everyone else downtown, at cal ave etc. I remember a Palo Alto person-on-the-street question about "what's your favorite shop?" and the person replied "Woolworth's, because I can afford things there". No woolies or other discount shops downtown any more. The SROs are now boutique hotels. I used to live in Professorville in a house with 10 people and a band in the basement and we got along with our neighbors just fine. Even over-loud parties were handled in a friendly fashion. Nowadays the cops get called on anything, kids jump in front of trains...too much freaking out instead of freaks. What happened to SF has been exported to Silicon Valley as well.
- rossdavidh 8y agoHmmm...while there is definitely a difference between owners and renters, the article is talking in large part about the attitudes of renters: "But, among renters, attitudes toward affordable housing were quite different. While renters were less likely to support market-rate housing the closer it was located to their house, for affordable housing the result was reversed." The question is why renters did not support more upscale housing being built, and rejected the argument that any increase in housing would ultimately result in an increase in housing supply and thus (theoretically) a reduction in rent. The answer is, they don't believe that's the way it really happens, and they're correct not to believe it.
- wbl 8y agoThese are renters renting market rate units.
- arcticbull 8y agoLuxury housing by mine is going to raise the value of mine and hence rents no? Sounds like what landlords would want.
- gotocake 8y agoOh they get it, they’re just looking out for themselves. Property owners account for 72% of the voting block and have strong roots in the community where renters tend to be more transient [1]. In America, as a property owner, your home is probably your largest investment. The perception here for better or worse is that more housing means less demand for yours, so you lose money. It’s like wondering why the foxes don’t vote for razor wire around the chicken coops. Not in a malicious way, it’s just not in their interests. The corollary is that the people pushing for vertical building and high density housing, while dressing the issue up as being about the homeless, are also looking out for their best interests. They want a better place to live, where they want to live, where they can make 6-figure salaries in the sun. It’s important to realize that this isn’t a matter of chickens and foxes, and there’s a reason why the focus is inevitably in areas where they can earn the most and where they would like to live. The truth is that every aspect of this debate is shrouded in hypocrisy, because otherwise it boils down to people wanting massive new infrastructure to support their desires, or people supporting a deeply imperfect status quo because they’re already winners in it. One side justifies their desire for a slice of the pie by looking to trickle-down economics for housing, clsiming that they care about the less fortunate. The claims that the techies making their property even more valuable through demand are a plague of locust ruining their fair cities. Both are more or less full of it.
- arcticbull 8y agoBuilding up is the only sustainable way to house us all. Yeah the character and fabric of the city will change but I have a hard time believing the people in Hong Kong long for a time of 3 story houses but I suppose I could be mistaken.
- jimmaswell 8y agoDoes anybody really /want/ to live in Hong Kong?
- thesausageking 8y agoIf they had a larger tech ecosystem, I would prefer Hong Kong to SF or most American cities. Amazing food, great public transit, miles and miles of hiking trails through the mountains, international and varied culture (to SF's tech monoculture), and it's very safe where ever you go.