3 ms·
Yep, there’s going to be a lot of hand wringing, finger pointing and hot air expended over the next few years and this is basically it. Boeing had two options:
by arcticbull 8y ago
Yep, there’s going to be a lot of hand wringing, finger pointing and hot air expended over the next few years and this is basically it. Boeing had two options:
(1) 3 sensors plus majority voter.
(2) A mandatory AoA disagree indication plus some training on how to react to it.
They chose option (3): Neither. Frankly when I heard there were just two sensors and no disagree indication, my first thought was well that’s just as good as one sensor and hoping for the best, isn’t it? The “challenger moment” would have been after the meeting they decided on this.
- Animats 8y agoThat's what really amazes me. Especially since AoA vanes are known to be troublesome.[1] In most aircraft they just trigger the stall warning horn and stick shaker; they don't directly affect aircraft control. [1] https://mooneyspace.com/topic/19801-stall-warningaoa-failure-poll/ https://mooneyspace.com/topic/19801-stall-warningaoa-failure...
- cjbprime 8y agoI think Airbus will disable the autopilot in case of AoA sensor failure, which is why it has three of them instead of two.
- cjbprime 8y agoIt's more literally "just one sensor" than you say, I think. MCAS doesn't average or anything: it just picks one sensor at a time arbitrarily and uses it. (This will change in next month's software fix.) (2) sounds like it could be airworthy, but I think Boeing might instead find that it has to add that third sensor. Airbus has three, and any rationale that Boeing only needs two because the disagreement consequences are not severe seems atop quicksand at this point.
- D_Alex 8y agoOption (4): input from other sensors (altitude, climb rate, gyroscope/artificial horizon, pilot actions etc) for a sense check...?
- arcticbull 8y agoMy gut tells me aerospace errs on the side of simplicity and reproducibility. It could work, though ideally system errors wouldn’t interfere with other systems.
- 7952 8y agoAnd the engine stats should be a good source of data.
- 7952 8y agoIt is worth pointing out that an AOA sensor should not be critical for normal flight. If a sensor is faulty then why not simply stop using angle of attack as a data point. It should still be perfectly possible to fly safely and using a configuration that will avoid a stall. Pilots should be able to fly on a minimum set of instruments.