5 ms·
Agreed - details matter a lot. For example many years ago, Camden in London put in green asphalt cycle paths - one was dangerously hilarious - you ran parallel
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
Agreed - details matter a lot. For example many years ago, Camden in London put in green asphalt cycle paths - one was dangerously hilarious - you ran parallel to the main road, on a painted strip, on the side of a one way street - going against the traffic.
However the new cycle "superhighways" in London are a big improvement but oddly now I find the biggest challenge is to change the attitude of the cyclists - we have effectively been given roads - and so now need to obey the laws of the road - it's a toss up if every cyclist will stop at the traffic lights for these superhighways - frustrating if you are a fellow cyclist and dangerous if you are crossing
At some point however we are going to face the fact that roads are a cheap form of transport because they are shared and so are dangerous - the UK has 4500 deaths a year - and when we look at segregating cycle traffic to make it safer we realise it is effectively asking to build a railway- and we shall face the same as self driving vehicles get close to good enough but plateau out - and I bet the business case for self driving cars rarely has ever been coated with "we build segregated roads everywhere with huge fences to keep out pedestrians and other hard to avoid objects."
- gotocake 8y agoAt some point however we are going to face the fact that roads are a cheap form of transport because they are shared and so are dangerous - the UK has 4500 deaths a year Well that’s untrue. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reported_Road_Casualties_Great_Britain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reported_Road_Casualties_Gre... As you can see road casualties have been dropping for quite a while, and for the last 5+ years the rate is around 1,700. Deaths per year haven’t been near 4500 since the 90’s. This also reflects another reality you ignore, which is that road fatalities are not evenly distributed. Being drunk, driving tired, owning an unsafe or poorly maintained car, driving too fast, all contribute to risk, and all are avoidable. You also picked the UK, which has an extensive rail system.
- bosie 8y agoNot trying to argue the 4500 death as that seems wrong according to your link. however, i never understood the focus on "killed" as that seems to be a combination of things, i.e. EMT, medical services, car safety for example. Why not measure the accident by impact (that would keep it consistent over time). Also, what happened in 2010?
- gotocake 8y agoPer the same link all forms of injury have also dropped, from serious to minor. They’ve been dropping for decades, despite rising population, car ownership, and traffic rates (with the exception of 2010).
- usrusr 8y agoSorry to be the annoying guy pointlessly arguing semantics, but how can it be a "superhighway" when there are lights blocking traffic? Projects like that would be just as much of an improvement without the deceptive branding. To me, it's a sign of disrespect: give them what they want, but mock them with exaggerated naming.
- desas 8y agoHighways can have lights blocking traffic in the UK, is there a different meaning in the US? Superhighways and quietways are being merged and rebranded Cycleways soon.