3 ms·
I'm no Gates Foundation fan, but their unlike every other group that attempted to tackle educational issues, they were relatively honest about good and bad and
by bsder 8y ago
I'm no Gates Foundation fan, but their unlike every other group that attempted to tackle educational issues, they were relatively honest about good and bad and they documented it.
The problem is that they found what everybody knows but doesn't want to admit. The current public school system is about optimal for the amount of resource being spent. There is no mythical "pile of waste" that you can magically draw from.
They found that focused resource does help outcomes, but in far less proportion than the increase. If you want 5% improvement in achievement, you need closer to 25% increase in resource--and it needs to be sustained over years. More teachers that are better qualified is a good idea, but that is also the most expensive choice. And, your most effective option is to spend almost all your resource on the lowest achievers. All of these are highly politically unpalatable in the US.
- specialist 8y ago"...optimal for the amount of resource being spent." Belated reply, catching up on my reading. This is a very interesting point. I live in a largish school district. I've long believed, but cannot prove, that it's just too big. eg Scale matters. Everyone I've ever met who has ties to the district agrees with me. I know the CFO. He crunched some numbers, comparing cost per student and outcomes. Although he wouldn't share the data with me (political suicide), he related that the it's a bathtub distribution. So, I believe, but cannot prove, there's an optimal range for most organizations, and education reformers would get a lot of mileage out of correct sizing their districts.