4 ms·
> When upgrading the cockpit with a digital display, he said, his team wanted to redesign the layout of information to give pilots more data that were easier to
by rsynnott 8y ago
> When upgrading the cockpit with a digital display, he said, his team wanted to redesign the layout of information to give pilots more data that were easier to read. But that might have required new pilot training. So instead, they simply recreated the decades-old gauges on the screen.
This was a particularly weird detail, I thought.
- cletus 8y agoThat's about common type ratings. With the same cockpit, a pilot qualified to fly the 737 is qualified to fly anything in that common type rating. If the 737 MAX is similar enough to be in that common type rating, no specific training or certification is required. That's something Boeing wanted. Probably because the airlines wanted it.
- berti 8y agoWell Boeing wanted it just as much. If you need to retrain all your pilots anyway, Airbus becomes much more competitive.
- stefan_ 8y agoThat seems very sane? It's a more fuel-efficient 737; carriers and pilots want and need redesigned cockpit and instruments as much as I need the latest take of the Gmail design team on how a mail app should look and function.
- mortenjorck 8y agoThe process and rationale for redesigning a web app to drive engagement is not really comparable to that of redesigning an aircraft instrument panel to promote safety.
- Traster 8y agoI think this is a bad take - the reason why Gmail's redesign is bad is because the motivation is bad. They want more lock-in, more engagement etc. Stuff unrelated to being a good mail app. The reason the 737 redesign was good was because they actually could lay things out better and make things easier to use and safer. The reason not to redesign was bad - wanting an easy sell, and so the choice of not to redesign was bad, since you're not producing the best produce. Whether or not to redesign isn't the thing that sunk the 737 Max, but it is another manifestation of the same motivation that caused the problems.
- ekianjo 8y agoIt makes a lot of sense when you consider user adoption as an important metric. Familiarity will trump redesigns most of the time.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoIt's not weird. Pilots get used to a particular 2D pattern of repeatedly and sequentially scanning the instruments in front of them. When flying a particular model of aircraft, safety requires those instruments to be in the same place without the pilot having to waste even a second looking for them.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoBut that's not what Boeing accomplished. Previous someone posted to HN about the 737 MAX entries in the ASRS reporting system. Among those reports were complaints that pilots couldn't find the gauges quickly and that they were taking much longer to scan the gauges because they were so different.
- dingaling 8y agoIt's also incorrect. The digital displays were introduced with the 737 Next Generation in 1997. The Max cockpit eliminated the five remaining standby gauges, but all primary flight information had already been moved to flat screens.
- notjustanymike 8y agoSkeumorphic design, just like the first iOS emulated real world objects to help new users transition into the digital world.
- smileypete 8y agoDon't know the details, but maybe at some point, it could have paid to ask some experienced pilots and UI specialists what they thought would be best.