4 ms·
Just because a removal of freedom seems to be beneficial doesn’t make this any less of a human rights abuse. The right to free expression is inherent in all peo
by sneak 8y ago
Just because a removal of freedom seems to be beneficial doesn’t make this any less of a human rights abuse. The right to free expression is inherent in all people, and it is unconscionable that the Chinese government censors expression in this way.
- troquerre 8y agoThere is a world where we find that certain game mechanics trigger the same reactions in our brains as gambling, in which case limiting/regulating game time is not a bad thing.
- sneak 8y agoThey aren’t limiting game time. They are censoring publishers from publishing their game as written. It is absolutely a bad thing, even if you think the end result is a benefit - that was my point. Separately, the laws against gambling are similarly infringing upon basic human rights to free association and free communication/expression.
- Retra 8y agoHow is it 'absolutely' a bad thing, even in the cases where people are saying it is a good thing?
- saagarjha 8y agoUnfortunately (or maybe fortunately?) we seem to normalize violating the rights of minors.
- l24ztj 8y agoWhy should minors have the same rights as adults?
- saagarjha 8y agoOne argument for this is that these rights are granted to humans, not adults.
- sneak 8y agoThe rights that were violated were those of the publisher, by government censorship. They have the right to free expression, and Chinese officials will imprison them by force if they use it.
- nsillik 8y agoAre you saying that companies have a right to distribute their work, for profit, unlimitedly? Regardless of how dangerous, addictive, financially ruinous, or socially destructive it is?
- unshatter 8y agoFirst of all, the publishers were able to release the original game, but what was limited was their audience. If there were “rights” violated, it would be the minors’. Secondly, restricting minors from certain acts is very common in most countries because they aren’t old enough to know better. It is very common in western countries to forbid stores to sell alcohol and tobacco to minors. Would you argue that the store owner’s rights were violated?
- sneak 8y agoNo, they were required to institute cooldown timers for minors to be allowed to publish it. The same goes for Blizzard. Their original, unmodified game, as published in the rest of the world, is censored in China by media censorship laws. Selling alcohol and tobacco aren’t expression, authoring and publishing creative works is. Please do not conflate the two.
- nsillik 8y ago> The inalienable right to play Fortnite. All governments restrict certain behaviors: alcohol (dui, public intoication, etc.), drugs(prohibition, prescription only), gambling. Now, it’s fair to say that doing those, and doing them as much or as long as you like, is an inalienable right-like “expression”-is absolutely a position you can take. But all countries seem to agree that we shouldn’t do certain things, at least not to excess.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoAncient Greece had a couple major festivals of Dionysus in which it was perfectly acceptable behavior to get roaring drunk and stagger crazily through the public square. You weren't expected to do this, but you could. (One or two times a year.) It makes me curious whether having the rare festival allowing the activity might make it easier to get everyone not to do it the rest of the year.
- nsillik 8y agoAlso, see: Purim [0] 0: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purim https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purim
- thaumasiotes 8y agoI believe the European Christian tradition also had a holiday of this type, which was Christmas. But Christmas now is pretty different.
- nsillik 8y agoHedonist festivals were a lot more popular historically. I was born at the wrong time.
- kgwgk 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnival https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnival
- 8y ago
- ssnistfajen 8y agoYou must have not heard of parental control features. Is limiting a child's screen time also "human rights abuse"?
- antidesitter 8y ago> parental control features This is control by an authoritarian state, not by parents. But you already knew that, didn't you?
- ryan93 8y agoMoron
- dang 8y agoCould you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and follow the rules when posting to HN? We're hoping for much higher quality comments than that here.
- thoughtstheseus 8y agoNo, we are not talking about parents. Unless you are implying that people should receive their social, cultural, etc. values from a government?
- ssnistfajen 8y agoWay to escalate an issue about teenagers playing a video game. If you've been through a public education system you've already received social and cultural values from a government.
- a1369209993 8y agoYes. The fact that a large number of people abuse their children this way doesn't make it acceptable any more than it made beating them with belts acceptable back when that was common.