4 ms·
I mean, I'm not a big fan of Hudson Yards... ...but this piece doesn't seem to make any coherent argument. Nowhere does she explain why she dislikes it aesthet
by crazygringo 8y ago
I mean, I'm not a big fan of Hudson Yards...
...but this piece doesn't seem to make any coherent argument. Nowhere does she explain why she dislikes it aesthetically.
She simply seems to dislike that it was designed to be Instagrammable (is that so bad for art/sculpture which is inherently visual?), has some bizarre thoughts on climbing staircases (she's against climbing the Eiffel Tower as well, does she hate exercise?) and using elevators, and was unhappy with an attempted policy on photo usage that has now been changed.
Feels like fake outrage to me.
- notyourday 8y agoThis seems like a good response: https://nypost.com/2019/03/23/the-architecture-snobs-got-hudson-yards-all-wrong/ https://nypost.com/2019/03/23/the-architecture-snobs-got-hud...
- SiempreViernes 8y agoHa! He doesn't even use an actual picture of the finished thing, such is the depth of his interest in the subject. And four days after opening is a rather short time to wait before declaring "mission accomplished" on something that is supposed to endure.
- notyourday 8y agoPhotos of the Vessel are all over NY Post, Gothamist, etc.
- icebraining 8y ago> Nowhere does she explain why she dislikes it aesthetically. That's because her criticism does not seem to be primarily aesthetic. There's more to architecture than aesthetics.
- CptFribble 8y ago(one of) the other layers is that its only purpose is to inflate real estate values of luxury apartments that already were built only to be sold to the criminally-wealthy international investor class that uses luxury US real estate as a form of international banking/money laundering, while masquerading in the press as a "community" and the Vessel itself as a "public space," when in reality it is anything but. The comparison to the Eiffel Tower is to say at least that structure has a restaurant and a shop at the top, so there's a reason to go up there. The author does not seem to have special hate for elevators, only that an elevator for a sixteen-floor staircase that doesn't actually have anything at the top further reinforces the cynicism behind the design, which is in fact the major thrust of the article.
- mcguire 8y agoSee also the Gateway Arch in St. Louis and the Statue of Liberty.
- frozenport 8y agoExcept those aren't decorations to inflate property values.
- reaperducer 8y agoPeople said all the same ugly things about The Bean ("Cloud Gate") [1] in Chicago. Now it's a beloved icon of the city. People in New York just have to get used to it. The comparison to the Eiffel Tower is to say at least that structure has a restaurant and a shop at the top, so there's a reason to go up there. When the Eiffel Tower went up, people were aghast and hated it. They demanded it be torn down at the end of the Expo. But they got used to it. Same story for the big Ferris wheel in Paris. [1] https://www.chicagoarchitecture.org/tag/cloud-gate/ https://www.chicagoarchitecture.org/tag/cloud-gate/
- mcguire 8y agoThe author is: "Kate Wagner is the creator of the viral blog McMansionHell, which roasts the world’s ugliest houses from top to bottom, all while teaching about architecture and design." Judging by http://mcmansionhell.com/101 http://mcmansionhell.com/101 she has strong opinions which are not immediately understandable, to me, anyway. (It seems like she would believe most of the parts of Europe I've seen and all those houses in the US that have been lived in and built on for decades to be architectural shitshows. But I can't confirm that.)
- notyourday 8y agoIt is snobbery, mostly. How dare those unwashed masses live in those houses?! And those houses are "Ewww!"
- zwkrt 8y agoThe houses she lambaste are almost exclusively upper-middle class and high-class houses. I think she is railing against lazy/incompetent architects more than the owners of the properties.
- reaperducer 8y agoArchitects build what their clients specify. Those terrible parking garages at the bottom of square high rise towers? Architects hate them, too. But they're what the developers want because they maximize revenue. With the exception of Frank Lloyd Wright, Mies Van Der Rohe, and a very few others, no architect gets to hear the words "Build what you like."
- notyourday 8y agoThey aren't. They are from people who are stretching themselves into mortgages and those McMansions in the middle of nowhere are 250k-300k tops. They aren't three million dollar houses.
- zwkrt 8y ago