4 ms·
No, it lead to actual harm on billions of users. And Google did listen and reacted accordingly. But they still didn't put their hash to external scrutinity, st
by rurban 8y ago
No, it lead to actual harm on billions of users. And Google did listen and reacted accordingly.
But they still didn't put their hash to external scrutinity, still waiting for the pull request to get it tested with smhasher.
- saagarjha 8y agoStill, there's no need to be rude.
- rurban 8y agoI'm never rude.
- saagarjha 8y ago…I personally find that very hard to believe. Maybe you weren't specifically "rude" here, but you were clearly unpleasant–you called their claims "false" and "nonsense" repeatedly, which is rarely if ever necessary.
- rurban 8y agoCalling false claims "false" is necessary and not rude. And I just added Highwayhash now to smhasher by myself and my initial analysis was confirmed. It's the 2nd slowest of all tested good hashes, only behind Siphash. Every other is simplier and faster. Chi-Square on the lower 32bits was 0.00 so it's really a good one. But I see no usecase for it, really.