4 ms·
I really don't get the point of a blockchain in these situations where you start with a hard requirement for a central authority. What advantage does this offe
by tyingq 8y ago
I really don't get the point of a blockchain in these situations where you start with a hard requirement for a central authority.
What advantage does this offer over a normal database ledger, in this situation?
- sjg007 8y agoOne idea is that it will provide faster transaction and settlement times. Basically JPMC is a bunch of individual companies that buy and sell with each other already. Each time they transact and transfer money everything has to be proofed and verified. Adding crypto would ensure this condition by default at the protocol level basically. And using the distributed open ledger, they can have some supervisor process checking the chain to understand where the money is going. If this is successful they could expand to outside partner companies etc..
- bduerst 8y agoIs JPM really going to let everyone see every customer transaction on the open ledger? Are they really allowing third parties to mine blocks outside of their own servers? If not, this is just a database transaction with bells and whistles.
- lucozade 8y ago> Is JPM really going to let everyone see every customer transaction on the open ledger? No > Are they really allowing third parties to mine blocks outside of their own servers? No > If not, this is just a database transaction with bells and whistles Bitcoin is just a database txn with bells and whistles. JPM are making use of the time ordering immutability aspects of "traditional" blockchain tech. They're using normal distributed consensus on that because they don't need to solve the Byzantine Generals problem. They also have split public and private portions of the txns. They don't distribute the latter. I doubt even the public parts are distributed to non-participating parties (except maybe regulators) but I haven't looked that hard at it. All seems reasonable to me. And sure one could build time ordered immutability with Paxos consensus on top of an Oracle DB but why would you? It's not a particularly relational problem and a chunk of it already exists in open source. Which is presumably why they built on top of go-ethereum.
- seppin 8y agoNone, but it's blockchain so it gets a thread on HN
- jki275 8y agoNothing at all.
- stale2002 8y agoTransparency is the big usecase. All a crypto currency is, is a public append only database. There is no need to overcomplicate this. There are lots and lots of reasons why a transparent append only database could be useful.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lawn 8y agoWhich does not need a cryptocurrency. A public SQL database (which only they can alter) works just as well.
- sjg007 8y agoYou would still want to gpg sign your withdrawal and deposit transactions. You would need and want to audit for fraud etc... control the key server, manage write/update operations etc... At this point you've basically written a block chain
- bduerst 8y agoWhich can also be done by adding an extra layer to a public SQL database. It becomes a blockchain when JPM allows third-party, anonymous actors to mine the blocks and take control of the network, which JPM is certainly not going to do.
- stale2002 8y agoWhat if I were to tell you that Git is a Blockchain? Would you think that Git is useless, and should just be a SQL database? A Blockchain is just a public append only database that multiple people have a copy of. Despite people incorrectly thinking that this I'd a break concept, lots of things in the world follow this pattern, and it has been useful for a very long time. The method of "commiting" things to a Blockchain have nothing to do with proof of work, or mining or whatever. You can "commit" things to Blockchains in many different ways. GitHub, for example, allows owners of a repository to designate specific users with the permissions to "commit" code to their repo/Blockchain (which just happens to represent source controlled code, in their case). But there could be lots of ways of determining what is the next block in that Blockchain.
- Max_aaa 8y agoIt looks they want to move from a medium that they do not control (dollars) to a medium that they have full control over (their own coin).