2 ms·
I would say that none of your cases covers the intent behind the dictum. You've already moved past the "ambiguous language" and right into assuming that the arg
by naasking 8y ago
I would say that none of your cases covers the intent behind the dictum. You've already moved past the "ambiguous language" and right into assuming that the argument was clearly conveyed and understood, and so you must now endeavour to evaluate the plausibility of the premises, the inferences, etc.
The dictum applies prior to this step, where the premises and the argument may be phrased in a somewhat ambiguous way. When interpreting the language used to describe the premises, take the most challenging interpretation rather than the weakest/most easily attacked interpretation. When evaluation the inferences, once again take the most challenging interpretation.
For instance, a phrase may admit two interpretations, a valid or invalid inference. You should always assume your interlocutor intended the valid inference.
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoIf you find your interlocutor's position ambiguous in some major way, then you should, firstly, tell them, and secondly, ask them to explain. Otherwise confusion may ensue as to what exactly is being argued for and against. If the ambiguity is incidental, then the principle of charity is not really doing much. I take it that your example - about a phrase admitting a valid and invalid inference - is of this kind. Though I do agree that we shouldn't jump upon those kinds of slippages. If you read carefully and allow the conversation to unfold, while prompting your interlocutor to explain what remains unclear to you, then generally you can get a fairly accurate impression of their views. More often than not, the problem is not ambiguity, but an unwillingness to listen, and engage thoughtfully with others, through a genuine dialogue.