8 ms·
"Overselling is a dangerous strategy that can be counterproductive, even for the whole robotics community. Both companies and researchers publish videos of robo
by hhs 8y ago
"Overselling is a dangerous strategy that can be counterproductive, even for the whole robotics community. Both companies and researchers publish videos of robots doing tasks, but sometimes they fail to point out the limitations of the technology or that those results were achieved in lab conditions. This makes it much more difficult to explain to non-roboticist industry executives the difference between creating a one-off demo and creating a real product that works reliably."
This makes me think of automobiles - cars were first seen as "a rich man's toy", but Henry Ford worked hard to change that perception. He said cars are for anyone. They can be used to go to work, to visit family, to go sightseeing.
I still don't see basic needs like that being addressed with robotics. For instance, is it going to take out the trash? Clean the toilets? Fix the plumbing?
- seibelj 8y agoIf you look at videos of factories in poor countries that make textiles, trinkets, and other low-margin goods it is extremely labor intensive because labor is so cheap. Eventually, as the world continues to be lifted out of poverty, robots will be cheaper than labor. But they aren't cost effective for many tasks right now.
- gingerbread-man 8y agoThere's another advantage for which human workers that don't get nearly enough much credit: flexibility. When Tesla tried to create the world's most automated assembly line for the Model 3, they learned the hard way why Toyota and others have abandoned the idea: complex automated systems are, perhaps necessarily, tightly coupled and complicated. For Tesla, this led to cascading errors and insurmountable "debugging" challenges. Eventually it became evident to Tesla and Musk that, even at first-world prices, human workers were the better buy. [https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-13/musk-tips-his-tesla-cap-to-humans-after-robots-undercut-model-3 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-13/musk-tips...] When you think about it, the work involved in building software systems may only be economically justifiable right now because computers can perform certain tasks many orders of magnitude more efficiently than humans can. In the physical realm, the differences shrink tremendously (or even reverse), making it far more difficult to compete with human workers.
- lasereyes136 8y agoOn a trip to India I went to a Zoo where I took a bus to tour the enclosures for the tigers, lions, and bears. Between each species there were a set of gates to make sure the animals didn't mix. There were people who operated the gates rather than having an automated system that did the same thing. To your point, in India it is cheaper to have a human being do that work than a machine, much less a robot. It will take a long time for the economics of robots to catch up on really cheap labor in the developing world.
- robotresearcher 8y agoThe most numerous robot in the world is a vacuum cleaner. Autonomous cars are seeing huge investment. Basic needs are gradually being addressed, but it’s true that you don’t see it. As soon as something robotic works, people forget about it, and this is how it should be.
- est31 8y agoRelevant comic: http://www.artificial-intelligence.com/comic/7 http://www.artificial-intelligence.com/comic/7
- stcredzero 8y agoBut give it a humanoid form, a menacing mechanical voice, a bad attitude, and a zap gun, and the skepticism is much reduced!
- philwelch 8y agoYup. For example, GPT-2, a new machine learning program that can reliably produce realistic middle-school-C-student-level text based on minimal prompts, has faced similar criticism: https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/02/19/gpt-2-as-step-toward-general-intelligence/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/02/19/gpt-2-as-step-toward-g... Quote: > A machine learning researcher writes me in response to yesterday’s post, saying: >> I still think GPT-2 is a brute-force statistical pattern matcher which blends up the internet and gives you back a slightly unappetizing slurry of it when asked. > I resisted the urge to answer “Yeah, well, your mom is a brute-force statistical pattern matcher which blends up the internet and gives you back a slightly unappetizing slurry of it when asked.” > But I think it would have been true. The better we get at AI, the more we understand how AI works, and the more we can say, "that's not AI, that's just an algorithm that does <insert explanation of how the algorithm works>". OK, but there has to be some mechanism to how our brains work, right? How do we know we aren't just implementing shitty approximations of that mechanism?
- ip26 8y agoDo you refer to roombas or the classic upright vacuum? Because it's hard to consider the latter anything other than a machine or appliance. It has one button, one function, two states, and is controlled by a human.
- Ajedi32 8y agoYeah, once we have a more general-purpose robot that can fold your clothes, set your table, cook breakfast, and load/unload your dishwasher, washing machine, and dryer (or at least handle a reasonable subset of those tasks) we might finally start to see some progress in this area. Those are enormously complicated tasks to solve in the general case though, so I don't anticipate anything like that being available for quite some time.
- est31 8y agoEven one of those tasks would probably be enough for people to consider adopting robots. People started to have telephones back when you could only do voice calls with them. Then, the tasks that mobile phones could do expanded, first to PDAs then to the iPhone in the smartphone age.
- ryandrake 8y ago> fold your clothes, set your table, cook breakfast, and load/unload your dishwasher, washing machine, and dryer But are these pain points for a sufficient number of people? I can understand robots that could do these tasks would be a godsend for disabled people and the very elderly, but those are small markets. The vast majority of able bodied people just fold their own clothes and do their own laundry. It’s easy and takes minutes. I don’t think I’d even pay $100 for a robot that could fold clothes.
- ams6110 8y agoLaundry is absolutely the biggest "housekeeping" item I have trouble with. I would pay a lot of money (thousands of dollars) for a robot that would take dirty laundry and wash, dry, and fold.
- amacbride 8y agoI’d pay a similar amount just for folding —- especially with a kid or two and two working parents, it’s our biggest household time-suck.
- larrydag 8y agoI concur. Is iRobot considered an unsuccessful company? The basic premise of the article is if these organizations are being consumer focused.
- superqd 8y agoYes, exactly. Every robot from these companies I'd seen were underwhelming and nothing I would have spent money on. A robot that could do my laundry I'd pay $2000 for.
- cwbrandsma 8y agoAs would I, but I don't think anyone could make one that cheaply right now. I thinking of automatic milking machines for cows. Those things cost $180k each (which is why so few dairymen have them). I can't imaging a laundry machine for less than $20k right now...probably much worse.
- AlotOfReading 8y agoThat's both a relatively cheap price tag for a robot and a famously hard problem in robotics. You're in luck though, foldimate is aiming to launch this year for $1k. Given that a washer/dryer combo can be purchased separately for ~$1k, all you'd need to do is load each machine. Ain't the future cool?
- sbov 8y agoI looked at this because we've mostly given up folding clothes with our 3 kids. I watched a video of that machine and it seems to be more for people who hate the act of folding clothes instead of people who don't have the time to fold clothes. In comparison, our Roomba is a time saver because it means we don't have to do anything at all to vacuum every day.
- Ajedi32 8y agoYeah, the fact that you can't just dump a pile of cloths into the machine and get neatly folded stacks out the bottom makes it far less useful IMO. Still might save _some_ time, but not nearly as much as you might expect.
- AlotOfReading 8y agoThat's because it's fantastically difficult to manipulate soft, flexible fabrics. Building a [plausibly person-sized] robot that can reliably manage the entire laundry cycle end-to-end is hard to imagine doing on current tech no matter how much money you have. We're only going to see these sort of semi-partial solutions for a long time to come.
- bluedino 8y agoHome robots have been a dream since the robot fad of the 80’s. We’re not really any closer and a Roomba still gets lost in a living room.
- stcredzero 8y agoMakes me think of electric cars. Just a few edits: "Electric cars were first seen as a Maker project or "a rich man's toy", but Elon Musk worked hard to change that perception. He said electric cars are for anyone. They can be used to go to work, to visit family, to go sightseeing." Given that they're being built with autonomy in mind, wouldn't they qualify as robots owned by regular people?
- ragebol 8y agoRoboCup@Home [0] is addressing such home tasks, eg. cleaning a toilet, in a competition setting for universities. This is an attempt by last year's winners: [1]. Taking out trash is a new assignment this year. Note that in RoboCup@Home, the robot have to do a LOT of things well and its easy to be spread too thin over all those capabilities, whereas the Amazon Picking Challenge has a very narrow focus and you can still modify your environment a bit. [0] https://github.com/RoboCupAtHome/RuleBook https://github.com/RoboCupAtHome/RuleBook [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vx3QdaPD8bw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vx3QdaPD8bw
- hhs 8y agoThat's quite interesting, I like it - I wonder if they have plans to shrink that down over time?
- ragebol 8y agoShrink what down?
- hhs 8y agoThe robot. Would be interesting if the robot gets to a point where it's useful, reliable, and versatile for the home and its "owner". I wonder if this will spawn new economies as it did for automobiles?
- ragebol 8y agoNot sure how much you can scale down. To reach high enough to be useful, you'll need some base and proper arm to achieve that.
- snowwindwaves 8y agobasic needs are addressed by robots, they are just specialized ones called machines. I have robots in my house to wash and dry my clothes and my dishes! It is wonderful not to have to do these chores manually.
- jcadam 8y agoI still have to unload/load my dishwasher manually. Same goes for gathering, loading, unloading, folding and putting away laundry. Whoever develops a robot (or robots) that can perform those tasks is going to be very rich.
- petra 8y agoThere are plenty of kitchen machines offering to save a lot of time(instant pot, foodie ninja, tovala oven and others), both at the home and at restaurants(see spyce). They do their job pretty well. maybe not 100% but close enough. Same with laundry, roombas, yard work, etc. So now a robot gets all the simple jobs taken away from him, and is left with relatively little work to do. And this process will continue. So maybe, in this environment, we'll never see a generic house robot?
- badpun 8y agoI suspect that fixing the plumbing will require human-level intelligence. There’s a lot troubleshooting, strategizing, trial and error, trying to pinpoint problems in somebody else’s (undocumented) design etc. It’s basically like coding.