3 ms·
Robots are still too stupid to be used outside of niche applications such as military or heavy industry. In these applications, stupidity is a feature, not a bu
by bitwize 8y ago
Robots are still too stupid to be used outside of niche applications such as military or heavy industry. In these applications, stupidity is a feature, not a bug, as a robot is expected to only do the tasks its owner wants it to do in the way its owner wants them to be done. But they still cannot be expected to work alongside people in their day-to-day because either they're not smart enough to interact safely with people, or people have expectations set by C-3PO and R2D2 that the robots just can't live up to (something the article touches on). Heck, people routinely get bored with Siri and Alexa because these technologies pretend to be smarter than they are, and ultimately outside of setting an alarm or playing a song, the value proposition they present does not even meet that of the stupider technologies people are used to. Real, exploitable stupidity is at the end of the day more valuable than fake smarts.
So if you want to be a roboticist and make money at it, don't expect to be Dr. Noonien Soong or Dr. Light. You will spend your career building dumb machines to perform mind-numbing tasks for the world's militaries, factories, or fast-food joints. Adding smarts to robots is a moonshot project, as Alphabet learned with Waymo -- you need to be rich or have a rich patron just to get anywhere. That's where things stand now -- maybe in a decade or two, things'll be different.
That said, I worked in robotics on such "dumb machines" for four years, and it was one of the coolest jobs I ever had. So if you can land a job in one of the niche industries where robotics is really useful, don't let my desexifying the industry dissuade you.