5 ms·
I was homeless for nearly six years. I did my level best to never use a port-a-potty. I think they are generally gross. I think the only exception was one set
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I was homeless for nearly six years. I did my level best to never use a port-a-potty. I think they are generally gross.
I think the only exception was one set up permanently in a park as the only bathroom there. It was not as gross as the ones set up on city sidewalks, apparently usually for homeless individuals.
I really dislike most solutions aimed at helping the homeless. They are often solutions no middle class person would accept.
If you wouldn't want it for yourself, please think about why you think this is a good thing to do for the homeless population. It probably isn't. It's probably part of the pattern of societal behavior that helps keep this issue entrenched.
- cco 8y agoI use portapotties all the time, they're not unicorns and rainbows but assuming they haven't been defaced, i.e. poop or urine all over the inside and not in the receptacle, they're just fine. I don't see them as a dehumanizing thing. Shoot, nearly all construction workers use them as their office toilet, is that unacceptable?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWhen you are homeless, you tend to wear the same clothes for days or weeks at a time. You may be unable to shower for long stretches. Construction workers are going to go home, shower, change clothes, wash the clothes they wore all day and worked hard in. You seem to be taking it for granted that one can get cleaned up again after being exposed to a port-a-potty. This is not a given for homeless individuals. If you are in good health -- which many homeless people are not -- and have regular access to showers, laundry service, etc, using a port-a-potty may be no big deal. But this is generally not the case for people on the street.
- username3 8y agoThe solution is public showers for the homeless.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYes, let's just leave them on the street and give them lousy port-a-potties and shower access. That's the humane approach. (Do I need a sarcasm tag here?) That still leaves them wearing the same filthy clothes. It doesn't remotely solve the problem. Furthermore, homeless showers tend to be as horrible as most homeless services. Either you have no privacy -- because why the hell should your dignity matter when you are homeless? -- or it has mold issues, etc. All services specifically designed to service the homeless population tend to be really, truly terrible in a "you would get sued if this were aimed at middle class people" kind of way. The general attitude is "beggars can't be choosers" and "don't be so uppity -- show a little gratitude for the shitty service you are getting for free, you ungrateful whiner." So, no, that's not the solution. Missing Middle Housing is The Solution here. Or one part of it. There is no single cause of homelessness. There is no single solution.
- lisper 8y ago> There is no single cause of homelessness. There is no single solution. This is really important to emphasize. I've never been homeless, but I did spend two years hanging out with homeless people while making a documentary film. The range of people on the street is almost as broad as the range of people off it. I met homeless people with Ph.D.'s. I met homeless people with florid schizophrenia. I met homeless people with substance abuse issues. I met homeless people who were perfectly ordinary but had some bad luck (ranging from losing their job to losing their entire family in a car crash). I even met homeless people who chose to live on the street (or in their car) because they wanted a nomadic lifestyle. But no matter how you slice it, the only real solution to homelessness is housing.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou made an excellent movie about the issue. I highly recommend it: http://www.graceofgodmovie.com/ http://www.graceofgodmovie.com/
- lisper 8y ago
- peterwwillis 8y agoI noticed this weird trend with portas and how people treat them. I volunteer with orgs that put on big events and rent lots of portas. The attendees are "woke", and we give lots of warnings to not throw trash in the portas, to not deface them or stop them up. But they get destroyed anyway, and then we have to clean them out to avoid getting big cleaning costs from the porta rental companies. If, however, we have an event with "regular" bathrooms, they don't get as destroyed. One solution may be to construct "alternative portas" with a different name, that look and feel more like a european or asian home-model toilet+shower combo. I think this might cause people to abuse them less, if they think of them more like their own bathroom. This doesn't solve things like the laundry issue, or, well, housing. But most other developed nations have decent public toilets, and we should too.
- gadders 8y agoBut surely a porta-potty is better than going to toilet in the open?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoPerhaps better than openly pissing and pooping on a city sidewalk in broad daylight. But I spent nearly six years homeless and never did that. In the city, you can find proper bathrooms. Big cities sometimes have public bathrooms open 24 hours and with an attendant. San Diego had at least two that I knew of. You can also use the library bathroom if you haven't been banned from the library by staff for behaving badly. There are bathrooms at homeless services. There are bathrooms in malls, grocery stores, homeless services, etc. If you aren't in the big city, if you are camped in a patch of woods, you poop and pee in the bushes. It's vastly more sanitary than a port-a-potty. If you grew up in a semi-rural environment with a culture of folks who did things like go hunting in the woods, relieving yourself in the bushes isn't a weird idea at all. It's only in recent years that anyone seems to think it is. It certainly wasn't when I was growing up.
- gadders 8y agoThanks for the explanation. One of the things I hear about SF is the public pooping, so assumed that was a large part of the problem.
- cco 8y agoI have had two friends, one still, homeless. I understand, and do not take for granted, that homeless people do not have ready access to clean clothes or showers. Does anybody think that homeless people can just shower and do laundry? If they do I do not know them. Regardless you still are making portapotties out to be disaster zones, some are for sure, I've opened some up and there is human waste covering the entire thing and I wouldn't suggest that people, homeless or otherwise, plop down and use that. But portapotties are relatively sanitary places, they're a totally fine, emphasis on fine, way to keep human waste off of the streets. Having pooped in a lot of places I would 100% choose a portapotty over an alleyway or my apartment building's stoop. I'm a little surprised by your opinion as well, I can't speak for every homeless person by any means but the ones I do know would definitely prefer to see an unlocked and clean portapotty if they needed to go vs. having to go in an alley. Sure, a bathroom in their own home would be better...but that isn't what we're talking about right? We're talking about a public health crises and it is inhumane to suggest we take no action and instead shout, "These people deserve homes!", even though they do, when they're literally dying of Hep A.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm not suggesting we take no action. I'm just suggesting we take actions other than the one you are advocating. There is a huge difference between those two things. I'm actively working on this problem space myself and have been for years. I personally run multiple websites that help address the problem. I do my best to get that information into the hands of homeless people wherever possible, both via internet participation and handing out fliers to local homeless services and the local police department. (Here is an edited version of what I am distributing locally: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1L5CsLmHLPUV1uehvRtu17H9yL5iKFa_2PAH2mEK1L64/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/document/d/1L5CsLmHLPUV1uehvRtu17H9y...) I'm also involved (very part time) with two local non profits who do urban planning and economic development type work. Some of that I get a little for. Most of it is done pro bono. I cannot afford to just give all my time away for free and such interests tend to not pay. I blog. I do freelance writing. I edit resumes. I do a little website work here and there. Still, I continue to struggle to get by. I suck at promoting my Patreon. People on the internet routinely tell me to go get a real job and stop trying to monetize my online work and yadda. I'm a woman. I appear to be the only woman to have ever spent time on the leaderboard of HN. But being a woman closes a lot of doors for me. People here occasionally give me a few bucks out of compassion when I'm especially broke. But I can't, for example, get much support for my Patreon. There are no doubt myriad reasons for that. But I don't know how to readily solve it. I am not willing to create a non-profit homeless services thing. That approach is antithetical to my beliefs about how to actually fix things. I'm just saying that I have done substantial research on the problem space. I wanted to be an urban planner before life got in the way and I have taken a college class on Homelessness and Public Policy through SFSU when I was living in the San Francisco Bay Area as a military wife. I think I have a good outline for what works. I am interested in promoting real solutions. But unless I can get an actual job in urban planning or economic development, the odds are poor that I can find a means to monetize my efforts to address this problem. Some of those reasons are inherent to the problem space itself. Among other things, poor people don't have a lot of money to give you to fix their problems. If you want to get your city to build proper public bathrooms with a 24 hour attendant, I would be all for that. I don't support a policy of more port-a-potties. I'm okay with you being all surprised and what not about that. I'm tired and I think I left my best comments much earlier. It's probably all downhill from here. I plan on trying to step away from the discussion. I think I've made whatever useful points I can reasonably make. People can do with the info I've already posted as they see fit.
- czbond 8y agoWith your experience, what solution would you offer knowing the situation better than many here?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWe need to bring back housing that works for people without a car that doesn't cost too much. The best term for this type of housing seems to be Missing Middle Housing. http://missingmiddlehousing.com/ http://missingmiddlehousing.com/ Just as one data point, we have torn down more than a million SROs in recent decades while population has risen. SROs used to be a normal form of market rate housing that worked well for people just starting out who didn't have much money and didn't need much space because they were single and childless. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy We also need to resolve the health care coverage issues in the US. Health insurance eats up a high percentage of the US GDP. Most homeless people have serious health issues, either physical health or mental health issues. This is a significant contributing factor to homelessness. There are studies that show that when people get affordable health coverage, it reduces the risk of eviction. https://www.benefitspro.com/2018/12/14/one-side-effect-of-the-aca-fewer-evictions/?slreturn=20190222111041 https://www.benefitspro.com/2018/12/14/one-side-effect-of-th... We don't need "homes for the homeless." We need homes for the people. We currently tend to build homes for rich people only and basically shrug and say "not my problem" when the rest of the US can't make their life work. Then we act like homeless individuals are simply defective individuals and weren't screwed over by a broken system. No, they just need to stop drinking/using drugs, obviously. "It's just a personal issue." Never mind that new housing has more than doubled in size since the 1950s and added substantial additional amenities at the same time that the average number of occupants has declined. These changes in housing pushing up housing costs couldn't possibly be related, no. Ask anyone with a good income and cushy life.
- komali2 8y agoI think those are really good ideas and I think we should get to work on them ASAP. I'm curious if you have any short term solutions to give the people that keep pooping in front of my office at night a place to poop while we try to implement these solutions. I've suggested just handing out key fobs and the key for the first floor bathroom of our building but it was turned down by management. I'm not sure what we can do but I'm sad that the best option for a poo for whoever is doing this is our doorway.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]