3 ms·
If the energy was building up anyways, then wouldn't it have come out in an earthquake eventually? In fact, the later earthquake would have been worse. Maybe pe
by whatshisface 8y ago
If the energy was building up anyways, then wouldn't it have come out in an earthquake eventually? In fact, the later earthquake would have been worse. Maybe people will start intentionally fracking near earthquake zones on a regular basis to prevent the energy buildup from becoming dangerous.
- reallymental 8y agoI suppose the amount of stress/strain held within these rocks will be hard to ascertain. If these earthquakes occur periodically, sure that gives us a better estimate, but we still don't know the unintended consequences of triggering a quake. Not to mention the property damage.
- Symmetry 8y agoIn theory, 10 magnitude 5.4 quakes will cause a lot less damage than a single 6.4 magnitude quake. But of course if that energy were to be dissipated in micro-quakes instead the 5.4 quake is much worse.
- madez 8y agoIt isn't certain that an earthquake would happen either way. Take the example of a spaghetti noodle. If you bend it and it breaks, it releases a lot of energy due to the bending stress. If you introduce a defect in the middle of it, it breaks before building up that much stress. However, we don't know if whatever is bending the noddle would eventually do so until it breaks. Maybe it wouldn't.
- lifeformed 8y agoPlus, knowing exactly when the quake will happen can reduce a lot of damage. You can stop surgeries, trains, and stuff during that time if you have a warning.
- dhimes 8y agoYes. In fact, years ago it was suggested that we do that for the San Andreas Fault to prevent a catastrophic "big one" release. I read occasionally that fracking causes earthquakes, too. While there is controversy around fracking, I see the systematic de-stressing of the earth's surface as a benefit.
- lightedman 8y ago"I see the systematic de-stressing of the earth's surface as a benefit. " Those of us in geological fields totally disagree with you. If you start a small earthquake in San Andreas, say up in the northwestern section, you can trigger a full-length chain reaction that culminates in unleashing the big one which will rip all the way through Mexico. What is worse is that the earthquake will get stronger as it propagates along the fault line. What you call the big one in the northwest section where it all began is thousands of times weaker than what gets felt further down the fault.
- pathseeker 8y agoSo you would rather just wait for it to randomly unleash as the big one?
- ineedasername 8y agoIt does seem better than purposely releasing the big one, or doing so accidentally, which would be a risk until we can build much more sophisticated models that would guide these release efforts.
- lightedman 8y agoAbsolutely. Would you rather it be triggered by some person or corporation, and then have the problems of trying to hold them responsible for the deaths and damage that will happen?
- bcraven 8y agoWhat makes you think a man-made stress release will be any different from a natural one?
- snowwrestler 8y agoMaybe. It's hard to know if a later earthquake would have happened or been worse; it is normal for crustal rock to store some level of stress that is never released. You would need to know if the stress was changing, and how fast. If it wasn't changing pretty rapidly, it's possible it would have just sat unreleased for a very long time from the human perspective. Major earthquakes are rare; stress is not. There is also the question of what happens now that it has been released. Rocks are all connected, so a release of stress in one place might result in movement somewhere else eventually. BTW it is difficult to measure stress in crustal rocks remotely, without releasing some of it. So all of this is hard to know, and therefore hard to account as risk in new hydraulic injection projects.