3 ms·
Would it be fair to say, "all commercial planes should be safely pilotable with no computer systems working whatsoever"? How realistic is that? Where theoretic
by Waterluvian 8y ago
Would it be fair to say, "all commercial planes should be safely pilotable with no computer systems working whatsoever"?
How realistic is that? Where theoretically a single switch is flipped and your plane flies like they used to.
- baq 8y agocomputers are the whole reason why air travel is literally orders of magnitude safer than car travel. airbus is fly by wire, it can't work without computers. boeing at this point is most likely, too - i don't know about them other than i read here.
- Waterluvian 8y agoFor sure. But the pilots exist for a reason. It sounds like we are making it impossible for them to do their job properly when their intervention is needed.
- stephen_g 8y agoThey used to - you needed an extra person and a bigger cockpit. Computers handle things like the pressurisation of the cabin, power systems, etc. that all used to be managed and controlled by the flight engineer. They used to have a huge panel covered with gauges and controls. Generally for a lot of those tasks the computer is better at it than people... At the end of the day, this is more to do with bad system design, certification problems and lack of documentation and training about a critical system than computer control.
- VBprogrammer 8y agoAmusingly the 737 is about as close to that philosophy as you'll be likely to fly on these days. It doesn't require a yaw damper as (to Boeing's own surprise) it is positively stable in yaw. It's flight controls are directly connected to the elevators and there is a big manual trim wheel in the middle of the cockpit.