5 ms·
I think you mean American Psychiatry. Your use of Schizophrenia and Bipolar as examples are both at the top of the heap in terms of what modern psychiatry has
by cairo_x 8y ago
I think you mean American Psychiatry.
Your use of Schizophrenia and Bipolar as examples are both at the top of the heap in terms of what modern psychiatry has been successful in managing.
Depression, as a general term, and anti-depressants on the other hand, not so much. The world of psychology is far more of a fail. CBT therapies, mindfulness, and various other fads have all turned out, in meta-studies to be either hot air or incompetent application of the scientific method.
The human brain is the most complex organ in the known universe. At least psychiatrists are required to have an MD to practice. Psychologists just wave their hands around and maybe scrape by on some basic statistics to get qualified to rummage around like demented apes in the windmills of your mind.
- soup10 8y agothey don't really manage it well, the drugs they use depress all cognitive activity and patients almost always stop taking them. their cure for depression is pills that zonk people out too
- ddorian43 8y agoNope. There are side effects. And some times they are worse. But most times they're better than the disease. Good luck being manic with psychosis without meds.
- soup10 8y agonobody is arguing that major tranquilizers don't have their place for controlling psychosis in emergencies but long term use of them has a degenerative effect on the brain
- DanBC 8y agoCBT has a large evidence base and appear to work for 50% to 60% of the people who take it. We have huge amounts of data from the English NHS IAPT scheme. That number needed to treat is pretty good. You may want to compare it to other routine medication such as statins or blood pressure meds.
- cairo_x 8y agoCBT has been debunked by multiple meta-studies. Psychology, as a science, is a joke. The brain is the most complex structure in the known universe, but to be a psychologist you don't need even a basic MD. It should be struck off as a science all together.