3 ms·
> What happens when people realize transfer medium is being debased? They'll obviously try not to store value in that transfer medium. Arguably, to some propon
by WorldMaker 8y ago
> What happens when people realize transfer medium is being debased? They'll obviously try not to store value in that transfer medium.
Arguably, to some proponents of MMT/in some versions of MMT, this is a feature and not a bug. Economically speaking, stored value at rest isn't "interesting", it's a potential indicator of waste or inefficiency of resource utilization in current flows. I've heard the argument that the real "bug" here is the human psychological need to "hoard" stationary value/"keep score", which admittedly is a very hard problem to solve, but having hard problems to solve isn't necessarily a disproof of a hypothesis such as MMT.
- zwaps 8y agoSo you do not want to store value for things like retirement or risky times? Runaway inflation can make even intra-year saving impossible. If this is a feature of MMT, it seems they'd be willing to give up on a lot of civilization since be began farming.
- WorldMaker 8y agoMany MMT proponents argue heavily for raising strong "floors" such as minimum current flows to/through individuals. The general goals are often to eliminate "risky times" as a category altogether as a general safety net for everyone. Then things like retirement and disability and sabbaticals are merely "special cases" of the general goal of eliminating "risky times". Yes, it's a very different view of economics from a lot of traditional approaches. It's not a fundamental "give up on a lot of civilization", even where it is a general rethink of "what does it mean to be a member of a civilization", including such things as what should be an individual's guaranteed safety floor, it's still mostly just civilization as we know it today swapping what we today think of as edge cases (social security, medicare, et al) for more generalized principles (in theory at least).
- conanbatt 8y agoI find the idea that private firms over-save and the way fix that is to print money to be disagreeable, and not an application of scientific or economical mindset, but the mere psychology of wanting to get results today at the cost of results tomorrow.
- WorldMaker 8y agoSome proponents of MMT strongly believe that we already live in a world where we fix private firm lending/saving problems by printing money, in the ways that for instance the US Federal Reserve makes 0-interest loans to banks. That certainly has economics and science studying that today. A lot of MMT talks only about exploring better options for how that existing effort/flows is redirected, and if we would get testably better results from other more interesting configurations, not about creating some new tools out of thin air simply because they "want" to.
- conanbatt 8y agoIn my amateur economist models, I adjudicate over-saving as a symptom not the disease. It is clear that money issuing does not have a neutral effect (not the same as private firms investing, or private firms being taxed to fund a government project). In the end it comes back to the utilitarian-keynesian view that the government will be more efficient spending that money, or that such a thing would not have long-term effects on the exchange rate, savings, etc.
- WorldMaker 8y agoIn my amateur economist models, I explore economic systems with modified electrical engineering diagrams. Money as we define it and subsequently many forms of savings/over-saving are nearly as useless as Instantaneous Voltage (in Joules) or ultimately as abstractly uninteresting as Ground in a working system. It is current flows and movement that are actually interesting/useful, and the not very well defined equivalents for money to its first and second derivative metrics (electricity's Amperes and Coloumbs, for instance). I have no idea how many proponents of MMT find interest in such similar engineering-oriented views of economics, but general economic theories of inflation/deflation from that point of view seem so primitively useless versus what we know of, say, electric resistance, inductance, capacitance, conductivity, etc. I cannot tell you if my armchair theories are any better in the long term than the status quo or your preferred models, but only that MMT at least seems to be one of the few areas of economic study currently attempting to address them (albeit indirectly in many cases). That is also not necessarily proof that MMT is correct, just as my models don't ipso facto disprove status quo "wisdom".