3 ms·
>> Another week, another swipe at successful people. I don't remember ever seeing "swipes" at successful scientists, doctors, nurses, midwives, school teachers
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> Another week, another swipe at successful people.
I don't remember ever seeing "swipes" at successful scientists, doctors, nurses, midwives, school teachers, etc etc whose hard work has tangible benefits for the entire community. It is obvious that the article is targeting people who are successful at being "egotistical assholes" that "succeed" by harming everyone else's prospects.
I don't find anything strange in that. I find it strange that this is not a more widely adopted attitude.
- pcstl 8y agoOf course you haven't seen swipes at these kinds of people. All the professions you mentioned are strictly hierarchical and highly regulated, and rewards to them come much the same as they come to schoolchildren - due to the benevolence of a higher authority. When someone succeeds as a doctor, people are hardwired to think "they deserved it" because of the very human drive to seek a hierarchical tribal structure, while when a businessman succeeds without going through what is seen by polite society as the "proper channels", they are vilified for not respecting the structures of authority, regardless of them contributing to society or not. It is a very widely adopted attitude. I'd say over 90% of human beings find the professions you mentioned to be the most "respectable" of all, while businessman are seen as the lowest of the low. Policemen also used to be treated that way, but they've fallen out of favor a bit. I find it sad that people who don't feel the need to cringe and submit to their supposed "betters" get treated as troublemakers who wish to destroy the harmony of society, except at the highest levels of business achievement (which are in turn disproportionately lionized)
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoYou're saying that e.g. doctors don't work hard, or that the work they do is not inherently worthy, so their value is granted to them by a higher authority?
- pcstl 8y agoI am not saying they do not work hard or that their work is not inherently worthy. All I'm saying is that society tends to value professions based on how much they fit into and uphold the idealized social hierarchy, and that is much more relevant to the social appreciation of a profession than "hard work" or "benefit to society"
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI don't understand why you say this and where the claim about "upholding an idealised social hierarchy" comes from. Is doctors' work beneficial to the community? Is teachers'? Firefighters'? Nurses'? If it is, what is the purpose of assuming some other reason that this work is appreciated?