3 ms·
Even for non-technical searches, Google is becoming increasingly worthless. I think a lot of it is about giving too much weight to (its flawed) geolocation. L
by reaperducer 8y ago
Even for non-technical searches, Google is becoming increasingly worthless.
I think a lot of it is about giving too much weight to (its flawed) geolocation.
Last night I searched for "Vintage computer store $location" while I was in $location. All I got back was Best Buy locations, eBay listings, irrelevant Yelp lists, and local newspaper articles about computers in general.
Today I'm in a different place, but performed the identical search, including the $location where I was last night, and guess what -- helpful results!
Google is trying too hard to be Yelp, and not hard enough to be a search engine.
- mostlysimilar 8y agoI barely think of Google as a search engine for the web anymore. Modern Google is more like an "ask a commonly asked question and get an answer" engine. My problem with this is that the usefulness of web searching seems to have been sacrificed in order to be good at answering the common questions. It's great if I have a question a bunch of other people have asked too, not so good if I'm looking for anything more than that.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoIt's great if you want a major brand, shopping site, or easily answered question that wikipedia and sport sites can answer. Which has been the direction they've been going in for years with updates to prioritise brands, recency and frequency of update etc. Add in the search bubble from your history, and "Google knows best" including also words and considering even quoted terms optional. Not much search engine left. Course it makes it ever more useless for the difficult, the rare and the old. The personal homepage, blog, or random site with the best knowledge on something esoteric almost never shows any more. Bing isn't much better, DDG became best - it's certainly not worse any more - almost by default.
- mostlysimilar 8y agoWhat's interesting re: getting better results is how much my own behavior has changed in response to how Google behaves now. In 2006 I would never search "how do I ___", "what is ___", because "how", "what", etc. were just noise, and sites weren't formatted as a question/FAQ like that. I knew to use a series of keywords to find pages that contain the content I was looking for. I wonder too how much the decline of personal homepages, blogs, random sites, etc. has to do with how much harder it has become to find them in Google.
- azinman2 8y agoA very, very large percentage of searches are for local locations, which is why you see these cards and 'answers' as your result. Most of the time it's what people want.
- caprese 8y ago> Most of the time it's what people want. It really sucks being a frequent traveller, and frequent VPN user and having to REALLY go out of my way just to get some useful default behavior. VPNing through Iceland and now all the Google Flights prices are priced in Icelandic Kroner and not even a clear dropdown to change this preference. Try the URL hack to change the currency code in the get parameters and MAYBE get what I want. There are so many ways to detect this and assume this preference, and they opt for the most debilitating one. Many services are following this trend, all because of blindly following some A/B test iteration. Add the human sense back into it. And god forbid the VPN server you used was used by someone else doing something odd, welcome to CAPTCHA HELL! Where we make all the assumptions about what you want until search is no longer useful for you, but don't let you access search at all by assuming you the current user are the problem based on IP address alone!
- azinman2 8y agoSorry, but you’re an edge case. I wouldn’t expect everything to work perfectly when you’re VPN’ing thru different countries.
- caprese 8y agoOnly an edge case because: There are more and more reasons to VPN through different countries. There are more and more teams using A/B tests and completely removing the human element from their UX design process. A human would say "hey it makes sense to have a currency picker here, thats super easy since we already have this on the backend" The A/B test says "hey nobody taps the currency picker so therefore it must be REDUCING your engagement" When its really completely unrelated.