3 ms·
My only remark is that changing dns to an external server is detrimental to privacy, speed, and arguably security. I'll focus on privacy because that's the arti
by lucb1e 8y ago
My only remark is that changing dns to an external server is detrimental to privacy, speed, and arguably security. I'll focus on privacy because that's the article's focus.
The power of tracking comes from a central organisation being able to follow almost everyone. Having a birthday calendar on your toilet that your friends can also look at is not creepy, but a worldwide central birthday database might be creepy depending on how private you consider the information. Similarly, changing all our DNSes to 1.1.1.1 is giving Cloudflare, the NSA, and anyone who hacked Cloudflare or any intermediate router (such as your ISP's internal routers and backbone Internet routers), the ability to track our dns requests. If you leave it set to the default, probably your ISP, then someone would have to hack all ISPs on the planet to track all of it.
Furthermore, if you're not paying for it... I'm paying my ISP, but not Cloudflare. Unlike XS4ALL, the ISP I have a contract with, I have no legal guarantees regarding what happens to the data from Cloudflare.
- saagarjha 8y agoIn the United States, there are probably three or four ISPs that together serve a majority of the population. So there's not much difference there.
- SamuelAdams 8y agoExactly. And most consumers do not have a choice what ISP to use. So their options are either a) Use comcast's DNS [comcast has had a history of doing questionable things] or b) use another DNS like cloudflare that claims to be safe / secure / morale. Short of running your own DNS server, there's not exactly a lot of options.
- godshatter 8y agoOn the other hand, Cloudflare doesn't know me from Adam but my ISP has my billing information. It basically depends on your threat model. I'm pretty sure I'm way down the ladder for the NSA, but maybe I don't want an employee at my local ISP getting in a tizzy about me because I frequent sites they don't like. And who knows in today's world what websites might outrage them? I live in a small town. This might actually be a thing I need to worry about. This discussion is prompting me to look into dnscrypt as a short-term solution.
- DavideNL 8y agoyour ISP can see your internet traffic regardless of which DNS server you use. By using Cloudflare you are sharing your internet history with yet another company.