3 ms·
> Duke’s true “innovation” came not in the 1880s, when the cigarette machine transformed the production process, but in the 1890s, when business corporations sh
by legitster 8y ago
> Duke’s true “innovation” came not in the 1880s, when the cigarette machine transformed the production process, but in the 1890s, when business corporations shed the fetters of state regulation and radically redefined themselves.
This article runs off of this huge premise that there was no actual innovation, just clever and malicious rent-seeking. But do we really buy that inventing a cigarette rolling machine didn't actually radically reduce the cost of cigarettes?
Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater - innovation is obviously an important part of the economy. We should not confuse it with rent-seeking behavior. Even in this case, it was a simple Patent that allowed Duke to establish his corporate dominance.
- gridlockd 8y agoThe irony is that Schumpeter would probably agree that what drives a lot of entrepreneurship is in fact rent-seeking. However, to get to point where you can seek rent, you have to be genuinely innovative first. Rent-seeking is a competitive field!
- 908087 8y agoYou should try reading the entire article. > Duke was not the first to use the cigarette machine; in fact, all of the major producers used it by 1887. He was not the inventor (that was James Albert Bonsack) or even the first to use them.
- cmiles74 8y agoI think it's important, in this particular case, to note that Duke's "innovation" was clever and malicious rent-seeking. While there was some technical innovation in terms of the forming of the corporation in order to secure exclusive rights to the best cigarette rolling machine, this innovation was not Duke's but in fact his predecessor. I, too, am strongly against the throwing out of babies. But in this case is seems clear that the celebrated entrepreneur is being misrepresented. In my opinion, innovation is an important part of the economy. It is also my feeling that this innovation is all to often mistakenly paired with a fabled "entrepreneur", one who is taking a lot of credit for others people work. In this sense, this story about Duke seems like just another example of this common (and erroneous) trope.
- shadofx 8y agoThe premise is that 20th century historians rewrote history to fit their political-economic theories, not that innovation is not real. >None of these points is accurate. Duke was not the first to use the cigarette machine; in fact, all of the major producers used it by 1887. Nor did he have the best royalty deal for the most efficient machine; that was held by the Lone Jack Tobacco Company. Duke was not the first U.S. entrepreneur to make a success with cigarettes or to find a foreign market for them; Lewis Ginter of Richmond, Virginia, achieved as much before Duke even began making cigarettes. Duke did not force his competitors to merge into the ATC, and he was not its first president. The five major producers formed the corporation in order to gain clout in negotiations for the foreign rights to the best cigarette machine, and Ginter was the first president. No one checked the story against primary sources. Even a look at New York Times articles from the 1880s would have revealed telling inconsistencies and errors.
- digitaltrees 8y agoThe real insight of this article is not the role of innovation, but the unintended power given to one particular company structure, the corporation, to be shielded from obligations to act as a public entity for the good of society as a condition of existence. Remember, there are other company forms like a partnership that are not considered ‘legal persons’. This status as an individual person meant corporations could use public goods and accumulate property on a scale that no one person could (because a Corp can pool resources of many people and out bid others) while also being shielded from regulations in ways partnerships were not. The way I think of innovation in this context is this. It may give an initial advantage, but it doesn’t last and isn’t as big of a contributing factor in creating lasting monopolies as is the corporate form and the shield it provides against regulation, public obligations, and even the competition that future innovation might bring.