4 ms·
I think it still does. The topic at hand was censoring content on the Internet. The original parent referred to "Islamic" and "right-wing" terrorism because tho
by ModernMech 8y ago
I think it still does. The topic at hand was censoring content on the Internet. The original parent referred to "Islamic" and "right-wing" terrorism because those are the two most prevalent and growing sources of terrorist activity that foment on the Internet. Did the Weather Underground grow because of the Internet? Did left-wing communist terrorist grow because of the Internet? Even in the early 2000s the Internet wasn't that big of a thing, not like today.
Today, ISIS and right-wing terrorism follow a strikingly similar pattern: attract disaffected males on the Internet to communities where promises of former glory will be recaptured through the creation of an ethno-state. For ISIS, they coalesce behind the perceived dominance of the Muslim religion. For the alt-right they coalesce behind white supremacy.
Anyway, I thought this debate about calling out terrorism was had in the early 2010s. The left wanted to call ISIS simply "terrorism" because terrorism is terrorism is terrorism. But the right insisted that it be called "radical Islamic terrorism" because in the words of my family member "you have to call it what it is to defeat it". I agreed with that then, and I agree with it now. The left lost that debate and everyone started calling it "radical Islamic terrorism". Now all of a sudden the right wants to go back to blanket calling it "terrorism" because terrorism is terrorism is terrorism? I'm confused.
- leereeves 8y agoHave you already forgotten these? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Dallas_police_officers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Dallas_police... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Congressional_baseball_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Congressional_baseball_sh... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YouTube_headquarters_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YouTube_headquarters_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Baton_Rouge_police_officers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Baton_Rouge_p... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Chicago_torture_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Chicago_torture_incident These are just a few particularly high-profile terrorist attacks by leftists; there have been many more. We should just talk about terrorism in general now because terrorism in general is rising, not any particular ideology.
- ModernMech 8y agoWith the exception of the Congressional baseball shooting, none of those were called an act of terrorism. The word terrorism can't be found in any of the descriptions. They're just crimes. The Congressional baseball shooter specifically wasn't part of an online community the same way ISIS and alt-right terrorists are. How would censoring online recruitment of terrorist activities stop something like a crazy person showing up to a baseball game and shooting everyone? > terrorism in general is rising, not any particular ideology. The study I posted above from UMD says otherwise -- that religious and right wing terrorism is increasing in recent years.
- leereeves 8y agoCalled an act of terrorism by who? They were acts of violence with a political motivation. That's terrorism. Even the SPLC called the BLM-related shootings terrorism. ("As details developed about the Dallas, Baton Rouge and St. Louis attacks, it was apparent that a domestic terrorist threat had re-emerged — a threat not seen since the 1970s.")[1] > The study I posted above from UMD says otherwise The study that (unlike the SPLC) doesn't acknowledge the existence of "violent black nationalism" (the SPLC's term), classifying those acts instead as merely "anti-police" and thus not counting them as left-wing terrorism? The study that separated environmental extremism from left-wing extremism? The study with a deceptive chart that depicts 210 where 250 should be and 190 where 150 should be? That study has many flaws. Still, I must admit the study does seem to say that left-wing terrorism has decreased, after being out of control in the 2000s, accounting for about 75% of all attacks. However, the DHS, under Obama's leadership, concluded that left wing terrorism is increasing: "Federal authorities have been warning state and local officials since early 2016 that leftist extremists known as “antifa” had become increasingly confrontational and dangerous, so much so that the Department of Homeland Security formally classified their activities as domestic terrorist violence" Previously unreported documents disclose that by April 2016, authorities believed that “anarchist extremists” were the primary instigators of violence at public rallies against a range of targets. They were blamed by authorities for attacks on the police, government and political institutions, along with symbols of “the capitalist system,” racism, social injustice and fascism, according to a confidential 2016 joint intelligence assessment by DHS and the FBI.[2] > Congressional baseball shooter specifically wasn't part of an online community He was part of several online communities where hating Trump and Republicans is the norm ("including the Road to Hell is Paved with Republicans, Donald Trump is Not My President, [and] Terminate the Republican Party"[3]). 1: https://www.splcenter.org/fighting-hate/intelligence-report/2017/return-violent-black-nationalist https://www.splcenter.org/fighting-hate/intelligence-report/... 2: https://www.politico.com/story/2017/09/01/antifa-charlottesville-violence-fbi-242235 https://www.politico.com/story/2017/09/01/antifa-charlottesv... 3: https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-pol-virginia-shooter-profile-20170614-story.html https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-pol-virginia-shooter-pr...
- naasking 8y ago> Did the Weather Underground grow because of the Internet? Did left-wing communist terrorist grow because of the Internet? You're inferring a causal connection here? Where's your evidence? Where's your evidence that left wing terrorism won't similarly grow? You're making a lot of assumptions to conclude that a medium which allows all people to congregate with like-minded individuals, will only foment aggression among a specific sub-population. Terrorism on all sides waxes and wanes due to many environmental factors. Assuming the internet is a causal factor, then when those environmental factors tilt against left-wing agendas, left-wing terrorism will also increase again. If the idea is to implement some measures to reduce all forms of terrorism and extremism, then the qualifiers are not appropriate in that context. In so far as some forms of terrorism may require measures that differ from those required by other forms, then qualifiers are appropriate. That isn't the case when you're asserting a mission statement or a larger social goal. However, the data suggests that left and right wing people are not that different, cognitively. They each exhibit similar motivations to deny science, a similar propensity to believe fake news. They differ primarily in their moral foundations, and so their propensity to violence will only increase when the environment is unfavourable to those foundations. > The left wanted to call ISIS simply "terrorism" because terrorism is terrorism is terrorism. But the right insisted that it be called "radical Islamic terrorism" because in the words of my family member "you have to call it what it is to defeat it". Because ISIS is a radical Islamic terrorist group. They're not left-wing terrorists. If the subject of a conversation is a specific group, then qualifiers are appropriate.