3 ms·
My ICT people made me install sophos on OSX. Even when disabled, the hooks it had into the VM and VFS layers intruided into my life and made other applications
by ggm 8y ago
My ICT people made me install sophos on OSX. Even when disabled, the hooks it had into the VM and VFS layers intruided into my life and made other applications I depend on hang. Once I de-installed it, this behaviour stopped.
The moral of the story is that an after-market security solution not designed by the core architects is very likely to be buggy. They don't understand things. They make bad assumptions.
Windows Defender was designed by people who know windows. It works well on Windows because it respects the core architecture. If this defender is written in native OSX code, and obeys all the documented and un-documented OSX things, and if Apple staff commit to forwarding bug reports to Microsoft, it might work, one day, five or more years in the future.
Until then, I suspect like Sophos, its going to crash my Mac.
I feel like one of those curmudgeon memes with a "prove me wrong" sign on my desk at school.
- jeroenhd 8y agoBased on what I've read about the native "protection" macOS provides, there's no real alternative way to scan files on-access other than to place hooks. However, if you look at the performance on Windows, Windows Defender is one of the best scanners out there. While some sort of added bottleneck is inevitable (especially during workloads like compiling software or downloading thousands of small files (NPM/Composer/etc)), I wouldn't be surprised if regular users wouldn't notice such an extensive slowdown in their daily work. Perhaps to some extent the Windows and Mac version share a portion of their code, but at kernel level the Windows Defender system is simply incompatible with macOS. A redesign of the performance-limiting features is a necessity in this case, so I strongly doubt the "people who know Windows" were the ones that designed the kernel interface layer. Basically, expect small freezes during compilation, but not crashes.
- basch 8y agoDefender is one of the slowest not fastest, it's a product Microsoft acquired, not written from scratch into Windows. If Microsoft doesn't provide other antivirus vendors an equal surface area to attach to, it will end up as an anti-trust case pretty quickly.
- ggm 8y agoI think you kind-of made my point: Windows Defender demanded Windows experts. OSX Defender demands OSX experts. Now, remind me again, are they employed at Redmond, or Cupertino? I expect small freezes. I expect pretty big ones too. Your optimism is exactly what my ICT guy said about Sophos.