3 ms·
If Microsoft can make the Mac version perform as well as the Windows version, this is good news for Apple users. Apple's current attempt at antiviral software s
by jeroenhd 8y ago
If Microsoft can make the Mac version perform as well as the Windows version, this is good news for Apple users. Apple's current attempt at antiviral software seems to be "prevent infection by making it tough to run malware" combined with a very simple signature based system.
This approach works for people who k ow not to click strange links, but as long as people give their life savings away to scammers pretending to be the IRS or Microsoft, people will just open random software from the Internet as long as someone is telling them how to open the relevant executables. Linux is much the same way (are there even antivirus products for Linux other than ClamAV?) despite half the Internet running on mostly-unprotected Linux servers.
However, due to the lack of signatures available on macOS viruses, I do wonder how effective MS Defender will be. There's various interpreters and shells available by default which make it easy to write an obfuscated virus script for OSX (python, Ruby, bash, and so on) which is not as relevant ik the Windows world.
To the people who complain about "bloatware" being forced onto their machine: you're just as likely to get infected by a virus as the other techie people in your company running Windows or Linux. How can you blame your boss for wanting to prevent getting hacked? Apple's own AV is just not up to the task.
- soraminazuki 8y agoYou seem to assume that AV is a effective cure for people installing random software on the internet, but I have never seen proof that this is the case. Worse, there are many instances of poorly written AVs negatively impacting the security and performance of the system it’s supposed to protect.
- jeroenhd 8y agoIt's true AV software won't fix behaviour. However, plenty of software gets exploited. There was a news item a few years back when pirated versions of Xcode inserted malware into some iOS apps; several big software projects have had their servers hacked, serving malware through official download links. AV won't fix users wanting to launch pirated games or software from sketchy sources for example. However, it can fix malware placed on a system after an exploit. I have more faith into Microsoft and their Defender suite than any commercial AV vendor or Apple itself. Right now, people are using Sophos or McAfee or Bitdefender on corporate Apple devices; none of those have a good reputation with me. I'd strongly prefer Microsoft's AV solution over any existing macOS security suite. As for performance, any AV will cause some performance drops if you enable live scanning or during periodic scans. Having a macbook scan overnight does not cause an issue, having live scanning running during compilation will slaughter performance. The performance impact is up to how the AV is configured.
- basch 8y agoOf 18 products tested, Defender had the highest system impact performance, and the only product to earn the 1 star performance rating. https://www.av-comparatives.org/tests/performance-test-october-2018/ https://www.av-comparatives.org/tests/performance-test-octob...