4 ms·
It might seem odd to north americans, but I never received a single robo call my entire life. I received one spam call in the last 10 years, and the guy exused
by atoav 8y ago
It might seem odd to north americans, but I never received a single robo call my entire life.
I received one spam call in the last 10 years, and the guy exused himself when I told him what he is doing is illegal.
This feels a bit like “weapon laws won’t solve anything” and “social healthcare can’t ever work”. So either Europe is living in an weird strand of alternate reality, or maybe some problems _are_ solvable if you really want to.
- concerned_user 8y agoEurope has stricter regulations. When I worked in a company 8 years ago that were sending sms to customers with text like - your order is ready, please come pick up, etc. And we used company name instead of number as sms allowed that, only 8 letters but was enough for us, but around that time we suddenly weren't able to do that anymore and company we used to send sms through said that some laws were passed and we must use one of the numbers registered to us and that's it. I think that explains why it is much harder to do robocalls in some parts of europe at least.
- rutthenut 8y agoThat was never a law - you were probably just caught up with an interpretation by the service provider.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bewo001 8y agoIt's a regulation problem, not a technical one. In Germany --and probably in other EU countries--, the telco must make sure that a caller is authorized to use a certain number as origin. STIR just shifts that responsibility to some other entity. If a call originates from an untrusted network, you remove the number or indicate that it is user-provided and probably fake. It would help if phones would properly display the difference (P-Asserted-Id present or not).
- b_tterc_p 8y agoIs there a downside to doing this?
- atoav 8y agoNot one I would be aware of. The problems the German network has, has more to do with coverage, monopolisation and the state selling frequency bands for far too much money on dubious auctions. But this has not much to do with the phenomenon that spam is pretty much nonexistent compared to the US
- eli 8y agoIsn't it also the case that in Germany the caller pays for the wireless airtime when calling a cellphone, not the recipient?
- milankragujevic 8y agoIsn't that the case everywhere? The caller pays for the call, the recipient doesn't? Where are you? My grandma has a prepaid SIM that I call and she never pays anything, just a small amount every few months to keep the number alive.
- tialaramex 8y agoThe US had a situation where the following happened 1. They issued all their phone numbers according to a geographic system, the North American Numbering Plan. Most cities would have one prefix, some larger ones gradually needed two or more, but basically you can tell from a number if the call is local. 2. Calls to local numbers were cheap or free, because routing a call on a circuit a few miles costs essentially nothing. Just spread the cost over all subscribers, it's fine. 3. Mobile telephones exist. NANP is full. How do we number these new phones? Let's give them local numbers wherever you're buying the phone. 4. Oh, but calls for a mobile cost more. Do we make everybody pay extra for the small fraction with mobiles? No. Can we charge callers for calling a mobile? They'd have no way to know they're getting charged because the numbers are local! OK, so let's charge _mobile owners_ when they receive a call. 5. Then everybody buys a mobile phone. The end state is always the same, everybody eats the cost of maintaining a network and calls are basically free. But the way they got there was different from most countries.
- Heliosmaster 8y agoIn Italy my family used to get daily (multiple per day even) robocalls just a couple of years ago. So Europe is not a single reality, as always. Now that I think of it, it mostly stopped. Could it be GDPR?
- TheHypnotist 8y agoYou opened this up to a larger discussion - but you are essentially correct. These problems aren't really problems if you decide to act. However, at least in the U.S., acting seems to cost money.
- SEJeff 8y agoWell in the US the people responsible for the brazen robocalling can simply hire lobbyists to convince congress it is bad to limit robocalls. So our entire system is a bit broken at the moment when we have a terrible congress and a president who appoints questionable leaders (see the guy who he put in charge of the FCC ending Net Neutrality)