4 ms·
If you eliminate p-value then you can't have authors that search for anything with p<0.05 and then publish, there will simply have to be some other justificatio
by colechristensen 8y ago
If you eliminate p-value then you can't have authors that search for anything with p<0.05 and then publish, there will simply have to be some other justification. If p-value is gone it will have to be replaced with something and that something, the supposition is, will result in better science.
Writing a paper, you need to support your conclusion, removing p-value doesn't remove that need for support, it will just find something different, hopefully better.
- seizethecheese 8y agoThis could make it worse. Instead of hacking for 5%, maybe they’ll hack for the lowest possible.
- colechristensen 8y agoTo be clear I mean rejecting p-values all together (or at least requiring additional evidence) not the specific <0.05 requirement.
- afiori 8y agoFor some context in the article they do not call for abolishing p-values but for a stop of the "significant" false dichotomy. An example would be to explain the consequences of all the values in the confidence interval or even to simply reformulate a sentence from "no significant effect was found" to "our data neither prove or disprove the presence of a significant effect"
- rejschaap 8y agoDescribed pretty accurately by this XKCD https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- stewbrew 8y agoThe proposal isn't about eliminating p.