3 ms·
Alternative narrative: A great way to create an echo chamber of people with abhorrent views is to drive them all off of general platforms.
by mindslight 8y ago
Alternative narrative: A great way to create an echo chamber of people with abhorrent views is to drive them all off of general platforms.
- robbiep 8y agoThese groups all exist on ‘general platforms’ - ie Facebook and reddit. But it doesn’t help the situation- in fact, it may worsen it. People end up only connected to people that share their viewpoints; and specific discussions in groups or subreddits are not occurring on a ‘soap box’ environment where the broader community is exposed or engaging with it; so it flourishes, with sometimes toxic results
- ng12 8y agoReddit is pretty aggressive with it's censorship. In fact it used the NZ shootings as an excuse to remove several "problematic" subreddits.
- duxup 8y agoThey're randomly aggressive. There's little rhyme or reason to it. They shut down watchpeopledie after some content was posted there and got outside news attention, they have no problem with other subs posting hate and talking about race based wars, violence against minorities and immigrants and etc.
- threeseed 8y agoBut if you don't drive them off then advertisers will leave and it will cease to exist at all. Advertisers are the ones you need to keep happy not users.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- everdev 8y ago> Advertisers are the ones you need to keep happy not users Not many advertisers on sites with 0 users. You need both.
- duxup 8y agoAlternate alternate narrative: Not being on general platforms reduces the available recruitment surface area. We've seen movements co-opted from one thing into entirely different things fairly regularly. Vulnerable people brought into far more extreme views. The pattern seems clear with things like Gamergate that turned into a reactionary identity type thing pretty quickly. "Incels" where frustrated men feed of each other's anger and it just builds and builds.
- mindslight 8y agoI was talking about discussion being on general platforms, so that abhorrent ideas would have to suffer opposition. But maybe eg subreddits were already too fragmenting for this to effectively happen. Do you really think it is possible to censor reddit/faceboot/etc so hard that few traces of these "countercultures" show up, actually making them less discoverable? That's a much taller order. Even here voat has been mentioned several times. IMHO that's really all it takes, because the recruitment hook is when someone clicks that sibling link to /v/programming and sees a bunch of stuff they consider "refreshing", it having been pushed out of the mainstream discourse. Then reading those critiques of blue-flavored polarization dovetails right into reading support of red-flavored polarization.
- panarky 8y agoHas the Overton window shifted so far that now terrorist recruitment, grooming and organization is just a "counterculture" that's outside of "mainstream discourse"? And the solution to this is to expose them to "opposition" on "general platforms"?
- mindslight 8y agoDerailing the argument this way sure is an easy answer, but it's not a productive answer. Terms like "recruitment" and "grooming" cast the issue as being driven by some external actors, rather than an intrinsic result of polarization. There is a sizable quantity of legitimate people feeling marginalized by the "mainstream" discourse, whatever the hell that means. That these various masses of people are being pushed ever-closer towards unreasonable views is the entire problem.
- filleokus 8y agoYeah. I recently checked out Voat, as it was proposed as an alternative for reddit. Not saying that it’s representative of the whole community, but the top of /v/programming was quite, erm, different to what I excepted: https://voat.co/v/programming/top?span=all https://voat.co/v/programming/top?span=all
- holymacaral 8y agomy basic idea here is the success of a pro-freedom site (like voat) is going to depend on the character of the first movers. 4chan succeeds where voat does not because the site has a more robust base of freedom loving people, not all of whom are right wing. I can't even stand voat but I happen to basically agree with em on a lot.
- fratlas 8y agoOh wow, Australian ISPs have blocked voat/4chan/8chan