3 ms·
Something I find helpful when doing statistics is to clearly state exactly what you’re trying to show or calculate before you calculate anything. “with 95% con
by amluto 8y ago
Something I find helpful when doing statistics is to clearly state exactly what you’re trying to show or calculate before you calculate anything. “with 95% confidence level and a .1 confidence interval” is not clearly stated.
Here’s something you might credibly calculate: if you ask n scientists a yes/no question, but actually only half of scientists worldwide think “yes”, then what’s the chance that m or more of them in your sample say “yes”? The answer is the p value, and it’s not very hard to calculate.
The point of this article is that many, many papers do this calculation and ascribe totally inappropriate meaning to it. And, of course, when you clearly state what you actually calculated, it’s pretty obvious that it’s a terrible way to draw conclusions about what fraction of scientists think “yes”. This is the point of the Nature paper.
P.S. I don’t know what you’re trying to calculate, but I think you did it wrong. If you want your calculation checked, can you clarify your question?
- jpatokal 8y agoIt was meant to be tongue firmly in cheek. Poe's law strikes again...